Ukrainian Army Drafts Israeli Breslov Hasid, Provides Holiday Items
Yonatan Karlinsky, a Breslov Hasid with dual Israeli-Ukrainian citizenship, who was conscripted into the Ukrainian army, received the "Four Species" (etrog, lulav, hadassim, aravot) needed to observe the Sukkot holiday. The items were delivered to him on Thursday at a detention facility near Odessa, where he is currently held.
Karlinsky, 49, was detained at the Romania-Ukraine border while traveling to Uman for Rosh Hashanah. Upon discovering he was subject to conscription, he was assigned as a doctor in Kharkiv. His family, who reside in Beitar Illit, Israel, had appealed for his release, but Ukrainian law requires his service as he was born in Ukraine. Claims that he was exempt as a father of six were found to be incorrect; he has one daughter.
Despite efforts by community activists to prevent his conscription, Karlinsky was not sent to the front lines due to his medical background. He was instead placed in a rear-echelon unit as a military doctor. He is reportedly the only ultra-Orthodox Jew detained in the current conscription wave, though Ukrainian authorities have intensified enforcement against all draft-eligible citizens.
Rabbi Avraham Wolff, the chief rabbi of Odessa and Southern Ukraine, has been providing Karlinsky with support, including kosher food and spiritual assistance. Rabbi Wolff arranged for the delivery of the "Four Species," including an etrog from Kfar Chabad, to ensure Karlinsky could fulfill the holiday commandment while in detention.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.
Ask About This Article
Duki reads it, and every newsroom on the same story, then answers with sources.
How the headlines differ
News Plus
One Event. Different Headlines.
See the words each newsroom chose, with the original headline beside the translation.
