IDF Chief of Staff Declares Hamas Defeated Amid Intelligence Warnings

Israeli military chief of staff, Lt. Gen. Eyal Zamir, stated during a closed-door security briefing that Hamas has been "defeated" and that Israel has decisively won the confrontation against the organization. The briefing, attended by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Israel Katz, took place approximately two weeks ago at the Gaza Division.

However, a senior official from military intelligence presented a contrasting assessment, warning that Hamas still poses a threat and is actively seeking to rebuild its capabilities and governance in the Gaza Strip. Ofer Mizrahi, head of research for military intelligence, noted Hamas's desire to regain control in Gaza, recruit personnel, and strengthen its forces, emphasizing that the group remains a threat.

Zamir acknowledged Mizrahi's points regarding Hamas's intentions but asserted that the organization has been defeated, citing its inability to retaliate effectively against Israeli operations that destroy its weapon depots, eliminate its leaders, and target those involved in the October 7th attacks. He clarified that "defeated" does not mean "destroyed," and the IDF plans to continue operations until Hamas is disarmed.

The military's assessment of victory is partly based on controlling about 64% of Gaza's territory, including border crossings, which is seen as hindering Hamas's ability to smuggle weapons. This assessment also considers the elimination of Hamas leaders, the claimed destruction of much of its infrastructure, and its weakened political and diplomatic standing.

Despite these claims, Israeli security agencies reportedly observe ongoing Hamas attempts to restore its capabilities in areas still under its control, including rebuilding governance structures and infrastructure, and recruiting new members. The report also suggests Hamas is trying to leverage humanitarian aid for its economic recovery, though its weapon stockpiles are believed to be limited. The organization, while significantly damaged militarily, has not abandoned its weapons or political objectives.