Israeli Finance Minister Backs Soldiers Refusing Gaza Duty Over Chaplaincy Concerns

Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich publicly backed 16 soldiers from the Givati Brigade who refused operational duty in the Gaza Strip, citing concerns over the presence of a female paramedic. The soldiers were subsequently sentenced to detention by their commanders. Smotrich stated that he supports the soldiers' right and obligation to serve in the IDF while upholding their values and faith, and adhering to proper integration policies. He added that the decision is backed by rabbis and leaders of Hesder Yeshivas, who have carefully examined the issue.

Smotrich expressed disappointment that the IDF did not prevent the need for his intervention, asserting that as a leader of Religious Zionism, he cannot stand idly by and will demand answers from the military. He criticized the IDF for what he termed a "misguided judgment" that confronts the most contributing segment of the public, potentially damaging public trust in the military.

Former minister Gadi Eisenkot criticized Smotrich, accusing him of repeatedly calling for insubordination and working to dismantle the IDF and undermine its command and values. He stated that Smotrich's actions create a chasm between him and the values of Religious Zionism.

MK Chili Tropper, chairman of the "Zionist Reservists" party, emphasized that refusing orders, especially during operational activity, must be unacceptable. He argued that any grievances should be addressed through established channels, not by disobeying commands. Tropper stressed that if every soldier decides which missions to accept based on their interpretation of "saving a life," Israel's security would be jeopardized. He found it concerning that a senior minister was legitimizing such insubordination.

The soldiers were tried by the commander of the Rotem Battalion of the Givati Brigade following the incident last Wednesday, which led to the cancellation of the operation. Five soldiers identified as leaders in the refusal received 10-day detentions, while 11 others received 5-day detentions, with sentences varying based on their level of involvement.