Rabbi Backs Soldiers Refusing Duty With Female Medic

Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu publicly supported soldiers from the Givati Brigade's Rotem Battalion who refused to board an Namer armored personnel carrier because a female paramedic was present. The rabbi spoke with the soldiers on Monday, praising their decision and reinforcing their stance.

"I want to say to all the heroic soldiers who did not board the Namer because there was a female paramedic inside, we are proud of you, simply proud of you," Rabbi Eliyahu stated. He explained that the issue extends beyond the soldiers' spiritual level to the IDF's conduct, arguing that for the army to succeed, it must respect its soldiers and their values.

Rabbi Eliyahu further contended that placing women in cramped armored vehicles during combat is problematic both operationally and halachically (according to Jewish law). He believes that including a female paramedic in the Namer compromises the fighting ability, the dignity of both male and female soldiers, and the integration of religious soldiers into the army.

The rabbi also addressed the conditions within the closed vehicle, where soldiers must eat, sleep, and use the restroom, stating that such proximity harms modesty and operational focus. He noted that this position has been presented to senior defense officials previously.

Rabbi Eliyahu suggested that the Givati soldiers' decision could influence others, stating, "Because of you, many traditional soldiers who have not learned to fight for their faith will benefit, as will thousands of girls who are thrown into such situations and whose modesty is harmed." He urged the soldiers to remain firm in their decision, asserting, "In your struggle, you are defending thousands. Do not back down under any circumstances."