Full coverage· Economy· Updated
Israeli Court Approves Class Action Lawsuit Against Dairy Giants
An Israeli court has approved a class-action lawsuit against dairy giants Tnuva, Strauss, and Yotvata, alleging they misled consumers by artificially differentiating between cream products to steer them toward more expensive options.
3 newsrooms · 1 language · sinceWhat happened
- 01An Israeli court approved a class-action lawsuit against Tnuva, Strauss, and Yotvata over alleged consumer deception in cream labeling.
- 02The lawsuit, initiated by consumer Uri Mann in 2023, claims cheaper whipping cream is suitable for cooking but marketed deceptively.
- 03The plaintiff estimates potential damages to consumers from the artificial product differentiation at approximately NIS 35 million.
- 04Regulated 38% fat whipping cream costs NIS 7.64 for 250ml, while cooking cream of 9% to 15% fat costs NIS 8.90 to NIS 11.
- 05Tnuva and Yotvata denied the claims, arguing that differences in fat content, taste, and texture justify separate marketing.
- 06Yotvata has added a note to its 38% fat cream packaging indicating it is also suitable for cooking and baking.
- 07The Tel Aviv District Court ruled that there is a reasonable possibility of consumer deception, allowing the case to proceed.
The lawsuit, initiated by consumer Uri Mann in 2023, claims that 38% fat cream is marketed primarily as "whipping cream," creating a false impression that it is unsuitable for cooking. This allegedly leads consumers to buy lower-fat "cooking cream" (9% to 15% fat) for dishes like sauces and pasta, which is sold at a higher price. While a 250ml carton of regulated 38% fat whipping cream costs NIS 7.64, the same volume of cooking cream ranges from NIS 8.90 to NIS 11. The plaintiff estimates potential damages to consumers at approximately NIS 35 million.
Tnuva and Yotvata denied the claims, arguing that "whipping cream" indicates a common use rather than an exclusive one, and that differences in fat content, taste, and texture justify separate marketing. Yotvata has since added a note to its 38% fat cream packaging stating it is also suitable for cooking and baking. The Tel Aviv District Court ruled that there is a reasonable possibility of consumer deception, allowing the case to proceed.
Summarized by baba from the reports of 3 newsrooms. Updated
Latest report: Ice. Read Ice’s originalThe coverage
3 newsrooms on this story
Who covered it
- Left1
- CentreNone
- RightNone
- HarediNone
- ArabNone
- Other2
