מינוי Plus

התחברות ל-baba News

חשבון אחד לאתר, לאייפון ולאנדרואיד — המנוי נשאר איתכם.

או קוד במייל

חיפוש סיפורים

הקלידו לפחות שני תווים. התוצאות מגיעות מכל המערכות ש-baba קורא.

↑↓ למעבר · ↵ לפתיחה · esc לסגירה

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי להמשיך לשאול. News Plus מסיר את המגבלה היומית.

או קוד במייל

Behadrei Haredimביטחון

District Court Judges Criticize Supreme Court Over Lenient Stance on Criminals

תומצת מתוך Behadrei Haredim על ידי baba

דתיטון טעון

עברית · 2 מערכות מסקרות

District court judges in Israel have sharply criticized Supreme Court justices for what they see as a lenient approach to dangerous criminals and interference in judicial decisions. Concerns were raised about mandatory probation reports in serious cases, the use of dangerousness presumptions, and regional crime differences. The Supreme Court justices acknowledged differing opinions, while the Judicial Authority stated the meetings foster professional dialogue on principled issues, not specific cases.

הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba

  • District court judges accuse Supreme Court justices of being too lenient on dangerous criminals.
  • Judges debated mandatory probation reports for serious cases and the use of dangerousness presumptions.
  • District judges from the south requested consideration for unique regional crime patterns.
  • Criticism also targeted Supreme Court intervention in legal cost awards in civil cases.
  • The Judicial Authority stated the meetings promote professional dialogue on principled issues.
District Court Judges Criticize Supreme Court Over Lenient Stance on Criminals
איור מערכת שנוצר על ידי baba News, לא צילום של האירוע.

Judges from Israel's district courts have recently voiced sharp criticism of their counterparts on the Supreme Court, primarily over what they perceive as an overly lenient approach to dangerous offenders and undue interference in judicial decisions. These concerns were raised during professional meetings between judges from different court levels, highlighting disagreements on issues such as arrests, probation service reports, sentencing, and legal costs.

In one meeting involving judges from the Tel Aviv District Court and Supreme Court Justices Alex Stein, Khaled Kabub, and Ruth Ronen, district court judges argued that the Supreme Court mandates them to refer defendants in serious cases for probation service reports, even when unnecessary. Justice Stein reportedly agreed, stating, "The streets are bleeding and the defendant should be in detention." Justices Ronen and Kabub, however, expressed a differing view.

Justice Stein also contended that judges are too reluctant to utilize the presumption of dangerousness. In another discussion, district court judges criticized the Supreme Court's handling of probation reports, noting that they face criticism for not referring cases for reports, and then for not adopting the recommendations when they do. They felt this effectively turned social workers into judges.

During a separate meeting with Supreme Court Justices Dafna Barak-Erez and David Mintz, district court judges from the southern region requested greater consideration for the specific crime patterns in their area, citing issues like agricultural crime and traffic offenses that significantly impact residents' lives. Justice Barak-Erez acknowledged the importance of regional crime characteristics but stressed that different norms or punishments cannot be established for different sectors. Justice Nasser Abu Taha supported the district judges' perspective, emphasizing his understanding of crime within the Arab community and the reasons for stricter sentencing.

Criticism also extended to civil proceedings. District court judges from the central region complained to Supreme Court Justices Ofer Groskopf and Yechiel Kasher about the Supreme Court's intervention in the legal costs they award. They argued that while regulations stipulate realistic costs, the Supreme Court often intervenes on appeal, awarding what they called "ridiculous" costs, which contradicts efforts to manage system overload.

The Judicial Authority responded by stating that the court system values professional, open, and fruitful dialogue between judges of different levels, and that these meetings facilitate the exchange of views and knowledge. They clarified that discussions do not involve pending cases and focus solely on professional and principled issues. The Authority also commented that the quoted remarks were fragmented, lacked context, and did not fully represent the comprehensive discussions held during the lengthy meetings, declining further comment on internal deliberations.

להמשיך לעקוב

Behadrei Haredimחרדית · ירושלים

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

ביטחוןנושא

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

מוזכרים

סיקור מלא · 2 מקורות
ראשון: Kikar HaShabbat · לפני שעתיים

אותו אירוע, כפי שכל מערכת דיווחה עליו בנפרד. פתחו כמה דיווחים כדי להשוות מה כל מערכת מדגישה, ומה היא משאירה בחוץ.

ידיעות קשורות · 1

לא אותו אירוע: ידיעות אחרות שחולקות עם הידיעה הזו אנשים, מקומות או נושא. רקע, תגובות והמשכים.

פתיחת המבזקים