מינוי Plus

התחברות ל-baba News

חשבון אחד לאתר, לאייפון ולאנדרואיד — המנוי נשאר איתכם.

או קוד במייל

חיפוש סיפורים

הקלידו לפחות שני תווים. התוצאות מגיעות מכל המערכות ש-baba קורא.

↑↓ למעבר · ↵ לפתיחה · esc לסגירה

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי להמשיך לשאול. News Plus מסיר את המגבלה היומית.

או קוד במייל

Ynetביטחון

Internal Shin Bet Dispute Over Human Rights vs. Security Balance Revealed

תומצת מתוך Ynet על ידי baba

מרכזטון ענייני

עברית · 2 מערכות מסקרות

An internal dispute within Israel's Shin Bet security agency has been revealed, stemming from a legal opinion arguing for a shift in the balance between security and human rights following the October 7th attacks. An operational official countered, accusing the legal counsel of hindering security work. The conflict reportedly contributes to tension between the new Shin Bet Chief, David Zini, and his legal advisor, and has reached senior political and judicial figures.

הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba

  • Shin Bet legal opinion argued for rebalancing security and human rights after October 7th.
  • An operational Shin Bet official accused legal counsel of hindering security work.
  • The internal dispute reportedly causes tension between Shin Bet Chief David Zini and his legal advisor.
  • The legal opinion warned of diminishing justifications for rights-infringing security measures.
  • Concerns were raised about international repercussions from Supreme Court reviews of security actions.
Internal Shin Bet Dispute Over Human Rights vs. Security Balance Revealed
איור מערכת שנוצר על ידי baba News, לא צילום של האירוע.

Months after the October 7th attacks and prior to the resignation of Ronen Bar as Shin Bet chief, a legal opinion circulated within the organization. The opinion, authored by the head of the Legal Counsel Division, argued that due to the ongoing war and severe security situation, the long-standing balance favoring security over human rights needed reevaluation. The author warned that Israeli Supreme Court justices would likely not permit the current situation to continue and that international scrutiny of such issues could harm national security.

In an unusual move, an operational figure within the Shin Bet responded with a counter-document. This individual claimed the Legal Counsel's advice was hindering the service's operations, citing the very legal opinion as proof. Details of this internal conflict reached senior officials in the Ministry of Justice and political figures, who shared the information with Ynet and Yediot Ahronot.

According to these sources, the new Shin Bet Chief, David Zini, was briefed on this dispute upon taking office in October 2025. This internal disagreement is reportedly a contributing factor to the tension between Zini and the Shin Bet's legal advisor. The legal opinion further cautioned that the legal justification for security measures infringing on human rights is diminishing over time, partly due to critical remarks from Supreme Court justices in various security-related petitions.

The legal opinion referenced specific Supreme Court cases where justices expressed discomfort or outright criticism regarding the overuse of security justifications. These cases involved the Shin Bet and pertained to legislation and government decisions impacting areas within Israel, the West Bank, and Gaza. The article also briefly mentions a separate dispute in 2025 concerning the Prison Service's food policy for security prisoners, where the Supreme Court ruled that current provisions might not meet legal standards, with one justice dissenting.

The Shin Bet's legal advisor warned that even actions with clear security rationales might not be accepted by the courts, urging the service to avoid testing judicial patience. Furthermore, the advisor raised concerns that the very examination of certain issues by the Supreme Court could lead to international repercussions detrimental to Israel's security. The internal backlash against this legal opinion was significant, with the counter-document accusing the legal counsel of impeding national security efforts. The controversy reached high-level political and judicial circles, including updates to senior Ministry of Justice officials.

Ynetמרכז · ראשון לציון

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

ביטחוןנושא

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

מוזכרים

סיקור מלא · 2 מקורות
ראשון: Ynet · לפני 16 שעות

אותו אירוע, כפי שכל מערכת דיווחה עליו בנפרד. פתחו כמה דיווחים כדי להשוות מה כל מערכת מדגישה, ומה היא משאירה בחוץ.

ידיעות קשורות · 1

לא אותו אירוע: ידיעות אחרות שחולקות עם הידיעה הזו אנשים, מקומות או נושא. רקע, תגובות והמשכים.

פתיחת המבזקים