Supreme Court Orders Retrial for Gynecologist Convicted of Rape Amid Procedural Dispute
תומצת מתוך Arutz Sheva על ידי baba
The Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Justice Noam Sohlberg, has ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was convicted of rape by the Supreme Court after being acquitted by a lower court. The decision follows a dispute over the interpretation of a proposal made by the judges during an appeal hearing, where the defense and prosecution understood that a rape conviction was off the table, but the court ruled otherwise. The retrial will be heard by an expanded panel of five Supreme Court justices.
הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Supreme Court Justice Noam Sohlberg ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman convicted of rape.
- The retrial is due to a dispute over the interpretation of a proposal made by judges during an appeal hearing.
- Shtetman was acquitted of sexual offenses by a lower court but convicted of rape by the Supreme Court.
- The retrial will be heard by an expanded panel of five Supreme Court justices.
- Justice Sohlberg cited the importance of legal mechanisms to correct judicial errors.
Deputy President of the Supreme Court, Justice Noam Sohlberg, has ordered a retrial for gynecologist Michael Shtetman, who was acquitted of sexual offenses by a lower court but later convicted of rape by the Supreme Court. The unusual decision stems from a significant disagreement over the parties' understanding of the judges' proposal during the appeal hearing.
The retrial will be heard by an expanded panel of five justices, to be appointed by Supreme Court President Yitzhak Amit. Justice Sohlberg stated in his ruling that legal mechanisms exist to correct errors in judicial proceedings, emphasizing that "there is no embarrassment or weakness in judging, a human act, that is willing to examine itself, and respond to substantive errors and glitches that occurred along the way. Quite the opposite. This is the source of its strength and power." He added that the pursuit is to render "true justice."
The case began in January 2023 when the Jerusalem District Court acquitted Shtetman of multiple sexual offenses, including rape. The State Prosecutor's Office appealed the acquittal to the Supreme Court. During a September 2024 hearing before Justices Yosef Elron, Alex Stein, and Yechiel Kasher, the judges expressed doubts about a rape conviction and suggested a conviction for assault instead. Following these remarks, the prosecution stated it would withdraw its request for a rape conviction and was amenable to an assault conviction.
Shtetman's attorneys, Yaniv Vaki and Irit Bauhorn, understood that the rape charge was off the table and focused their defense on the assault charge. However, the subsequent Supreme Court ruling convicted Shtetman of rape, contrary to the discussion. The defense attorneys requested the verdict be overturned. A subsequent hearing revealed a misunderstanding: Justice Elron questioned whether the defense understood the proposal as a mutual agreement, which, upon failure, would revert to the original charges. Attorney Vaki denied this understanding. Prosecutor Rachel Matar also clarified that the State did not perceive its withdrawal from the rape appeal as conditional on the defense agreeing to an assault conviction.
Later, after an internal review led by State Attorney Amit Issman, the State's position shifted to opposing the overturning of the rape conviction. The majority of the justices rejected the defense's request, upholding the conviction. Justice Yechiel Kasher, in a dissenting opinion, argued that a procedural error occurred that needed correction. Following this, the defense petitioned the High Court of Justice (Bagatz) to overturn the verdict. During a hearing before Justice Khaled Kabub, the rare possibility of intervening in a Supreme Court ruling was raised. Justice Kabub noted the lack of precedent for the High Court overturning a Supreme Court decision but expressed concern that Shtetman might have suffered a miscarriage of justice. He suggested the parties consider a retrial request as a way to address the issue without the High Court needing to overturn the verdict.
מוזכרים