Woman Left With Nothing After 17-Year Marriage and Two Children
A woman was left with no assets after a 17-year marriage and two children, following a Supreme Court decision that overturned lower court rulings favoring her. The court cited her affair and the husband's right to withdraw from a gift commitment as reasons for the final ruling. The woman's lawyer is seeking an additional hearing to establish clearer property division laws.
הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba
- A woman was left with no assets after a 17-year marriage and two children.
- The Supreme Court overturned lower court rulings that had granted the woman shared property.
- The woman's affair was cited as grounds for the husband to withdraw from shared ownership.
- A penthouse, initially awarded to the woman, was ultimately not transferred to her.
- The woman's lawyer is requesting an additional Supreme Court hearing for property division precedent.
A woman has been left with no assets after a 17-year marriage and two children, following a protracted legal battle over property division. The couple, who married in a Reform ceremony and lived together with their children, separated after a marital crisis. The woman was a homemaker, while her husband was a businessman and real estate developer who had achieved a significant financial exit during their relationship.
Initially, the Tel Aviv Family Court ruled in favor of the woman, recognizing a presumption of joint ownership. The court decided that four out of five apartments purchased during their marriage, along with bank accounts and pension rights, should be divided equally. This decision was made partly because the assets were registered solely in the husband's name due to his father-in-law's financial troubles and fear of creditors.
The husband appealed to the District Court, which overturned the joint ownership ruling. The court cited the woman's romantic affair as evidence of her "deplorable conduct," which allowed the husband to withdraw from any intent of shared ownership. However, the District Court still awarded the woman a penthouse apartment, based on a WhatsApp message from the husband indicating his intention to transfer ownership of the penthouse after their separation, suggesting he did not want her to leave with nothing.
Both parties appealed to the Supreme Court. The woman contested the cancellation of the joint ownership, while the husband challenged the transfer of the penthouse. The Supreme Court ultimately canceled the penthouse transfer, ruling that the husband was not obligated to transfer the property. Justice Willner stated that even if the message constituted a valid gift commitment, the husband could be considered to have legally withdrawn from it.
The woman has now filed a request for an additional hearing at the Supreme Court, seeking to establish a clear and just precedent for property division in such cases. Her lawyer, Dr. Guy Karmi, stated that the Supreme Court's decision is legally and factually flawed and could lead to further injustices. He expressed hope that the court would grant the request for a rehearing by an expanded panel to clarify property division laws.
אותו אירוע, כפי שכל מערכת דיווחה עליו בנפרד. פתחו כמה דיווחים כדי להשוות מה כל מערכת מדגישה, ומה היא משאירה בחוץ.
סיקור מאת N12