Rabbi Rules Matchmaker Earns Fee Despite Groom's Weight Loss
תומצת מתוך Kikar HaShabbat על ידי baba
Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein ruled that a matchmaker is entitled to a fee even after the groom underwent significant weight loss. The matchmaker initially introduced a very obese man, who was rejected by the bride. A year later, after the groom lost weight and appeared handsome, the couple reconnected and married. The rabbi determined that the groom's core personality remained the same, making the matchmaker's initial introduction valid.
הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein ruled a matchmaker deserves a fee despite groom's weight loss.
- The groom was initially rejected for being very obese but later transformed.
- The bride cited the groom's appearance as the reason for rejecting the initial match.
- Rabbi Zilberstein emphasized marriage is based on inner qualities, not external looks.
- The groom underwent surgery and a diet, significantly changing his appearance.
Rabbi Yitzchak Zilberstein, a prominent rabbi in the Ramat Elchanan neighborhood of Bnei Brak, addressed a complex halachic (Jewish law) question concerning a matchmaker's fee. The case involved a father seeking a suitable match for his accomplished daughter. A matchmaker presented a highly praised young man, described as learned and possessing excellent character. The father was enthusiastic, and the daughter agreed to a meeting.
Upon seeing the potential groom, the daughter was dismayed by his significant obesity, though she found his personality impressive during their brief conversation. She rejected the match, citing his appearance as a disqualifying factor. Approximately a year later, the father encountered the same young man, Yankeleh, at a wedding. Yankeleh had undergone a dramatic weight loss through surgery and a special diet, appearing handsome and slender.
The father, impressed by Yankeleh's transformation and still recognizing his excellent qualities, re-engaged the matchmaker. The couple subsequently became engaged and married. The matchmaker then demanded his fee, arguing that he had successfully facilitated the match. The couple's parents countered that the original match had failed due to the groom's appearance, and the current successful match was with a different, transformed individual.
Rabbi Zilberstein ruled that the matchmaker was entitled to his fee. He explained that a marriage is fundamentally based on inner qualities, personality, and piety, not external appearance. He stated that the groom was always the same person, and his obesity was a superficial flaw that was corrected, not a fundamental change. The rabbi cited biblical examples to emphasize that true worth lies in character and fear of God, not physical beauty, concluding that the matchmaker's initial introduction was the catalyst for the eventual union.