Court Rejects Daughter's Claim to Third of Father's Home
A Jerusalem court rejected a daughter's claim for a one-third ownership of her father's house, ruling her financial contributions were a loan. The father must repay 370,000 shekels plus indexation. The dispute escalated due to family estrangement, with the court finding no proof of promised ownership rights. The daughter was ordered to pay 30,000 shekels in legal costs.
הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Jerusalem court denied daughter's claim for one-third ownership of father's house.
- Judge ruled daughter's construction funds were a loan, not an investment.
- Father ordered to repay daughter 370,000 shekels plus indexation.
- Family estrangement and contradictory statements influenced the ruling.
- Daughter must pay 30,000 shekels in legal costs.
A Jerusalem family court has dismissed a lawsuit filed by a daughter seeking a one-third ownership stake in a house built on land belonging to her father. The judge ruled that the funds the daughter provided for construction were a loan, not an investment granting property rights. The father was ordered to repay her 370,000 shekels plus indexation.
The father purchased the plot in 2007 for approximately 250,000 shekels. Nine years later, construction began, funded jointly by the father (around 600,000 shekels) and his three children (together, about 1 million shekels). After completion, the property was rented out, with rental income split equally among the siblings.
Family relations deteriorated over time, escalating when the father demanded his grandson, the daughter's son who was living there at a reduced rent, vacate the house. The daughter then sued for one-third ownership, valuing the property at 6.7 million shekels as of August 2024. She claimed her father had promised the house would belong equally to his three children, and she and her husband relied on this promise, investing money, time, and effort.
Alternatively, she sought 1.67 million shekels for her investment, entrepreneurial profit, and work on the property. The father and his two sons argued the funds were a loan, with rental income serving as interest and the principal to be repaid later. They also accused the daughter and her family of alienating the father in his old age and stated no rights to the house or inheritance were promised.
Judge Hila Galboa accepted the father's version, noting the daughter presented contradictory accounts regarding when the promised rights would be transferred. The court found no proof of a commitment to grant the daughter property rights. Even if a gift promise existed, the judge stated the father could retract it due to her 'deplorable conduct,' citing the father's description of estrangement as 'they cut off my oxygen' and an incident where his son-in-law left him stranded. The court concluded the rift originated with the daughter and her family.
The claim for a future inheritance share was also rejected, as inheritance distribution requires a valid will, and the father is free to manage his assets. The daughter is entitled to the repayment of 370,000 shekels plus indexation from September 2016 within 30 days of her demand. Until repayment, she will continue to receive one-third of the rental income. Her claims for additional returns and payment for managing construction were denied, as the assistance was considered family support without an agreement for payment. The daughter was ordered to pay 30,000 shekels in legal costs.
מוזכרים