מינוי Plus

התחברות ל-baba News

חשבון אחד לאתר, לאייפון ולאנדרואיד — המנוי נשאר איתכם.

או קוד במייל

חיפוש סיפורים

הקלידו לפחות שני תווים. התוצאות מגיעות מכל המערכות ש-baba קורא.

↑↓ למעבר · ↵ לפתיחה · esc לסגירה

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי להמשיך לשאול. News Plus מסיר את המגבלה היומית.

או קוד במייל

Israel Hayomביטחון

US Jews' Post-Oct 7 Reality: Legal Protections Fail, Self-Reliance Emerges

תומצת מתוך Israel Hayom על ידי baba

מרכז-ימיןטון טעון

עברית · מערכת חדשות אחת

American Jews are experiencing a post-October 7th reality, marked by a loss of faith in the legal system's ability to protect them from antisemitism. Historically, Jewish advocacy relied on legal recourse, exemplified by the Leo Frank case and the Skokie march defense. However, recent events, including university presidents' responses to antisemitic speech, have revealed the legal system's limitations. This has prompted a shift towards self-reliance and defensive legal strategies within the American Jewish community.

הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba

  • US Jews now view October 8th as the start of a new reality, realizing legal protections have failed them.
  • The 1913 Leo Frank case and the 1977 Skokie march defense highlight historical reliance on the US legal system.
  • Recent university responses to antisemitic speech have exposed the legal system's inability to protect Jewish students.
  • American Jewish advocacy is shifting from seeking universal legal rights to defensive litigation.
  • The perceived failure of the legal system is leading to increased self-reliance within the Jewish community.

The article argues that for American Jews, October 7th, the date of Hamas's attack on Israel, marked the beginning of a new reality, experienced as October 8th. While Israelis realized on October 7th that their state and military could not guarantee their safety from existential threats, American Jews discovered on October 8th that their perceived security within the liberal legal system had also collapsed. This shift signifies a loss of faith in external protections and a turn towards self-reliance.

The historical narrative of American Jewry's reliance on the legal system is traced back to the 1913 lynching of Leo Frank, a Jewish factory manager wrongly convicted of murder. Despite appeals led by prominent jurist Louis Marshall and a dissenting opinion from Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes emphasizing the dangers of mob justice, Frank was murdered by a mob after his sentence was commuted. This event spurred the creation of organizations like the ADL and reinforced the belief that better legal defenses were the answer to antisemitism.

A later example, the 1977 Skokie controversy, where neo-Nazis planned a march through a predominantly Jewish town, highlighted the American Jewish community's deep trust in the legal system and civil liberties. Jewish lawyers, including David Goldberger and Aryeh Neier of the ACLU, defended the Nazis' right to march based on the First Amendment, believing that protecting even abhorrent speech was essential for protecting all. This was seen as a peak of American Jewish faith in universal legal principles.

However, the article contends that October 8th shattered this faith. The author points to the December 5, 2023, Congressional hearing where university presidents equivocated on whether calls for genocide against Jews violated their codes of conduct. These responses, echoing the legalistic distinctions made in Skokie, demonstrated that the legal framework that protected Nazis could not adequately safeguard Jewish students. The article suggests the American legal system struggled to define "Jewishness" beyond a religious category, failing to address political or ethnic persecution.

This perceived failure has led to a strategic shift within American Jewish advocacy. Instead of solely seeking universal legal protections, organizations are now focusing on defensive litigation and demanding that institutions specifically protect Jewish individuals. The author laments this change, seeing the legal system, once a tool for integration, now becoming a shield against a society where Jews mistakenly believed they had fully integrated. The article concludes by referencing the biblical story of Esther, suggesting that American Jews, like Esther, may have entered the "palace" of the legal system not to be protected by it, but to learn how to protect themselves when it fails.

Israel Hayomימין · תל אביב

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

ביטחוןנושא

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

מוזכרים

פתיחת המבזקים