מינוי Plus

התחברות ל-baba News

חשבון אחד לאתר, לאייפון ולאנדרואיד — המנוי נשאר איתכם.

או קוד במייל

חיפוש סיפורים

הקלידו לפחות שני תווים. התוצאות מגיעות מכל המערכות ש-baba קורא.

↑↓ למעבר · ↵ לפתיחה · esc לסגירה

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי להמשיך לשאול. News Plus מסיר את המגבלה היומית.

או קוד במייל

Makor Rishonתרבות

Israeli Thriller 'Bnei Gebal' Explores Ancient Myths and Modern Conflict

תומצת מתוך Makor Rishon על ידי baba

ימיןטון ענייני

עברית · מערכת חדשות אחת

Gal Harmon's Israeli thriller "Bnei Gebal" is set in 1997 and features a Shayetet 13 commando investigating a Lebanese spy linked to ancient Phoenicians. The novel, a prequel to "Mayim Shketim," is praised for its engaging plot and historical context, resonating with those who served in Lebanon. However, the reviewer criticizes the book's portrayal of a war-wounded protagonist's relationship ending due to his injuries, finding it overly deterministic and insensitive to the experiences of many real-life couples.

הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba

  • Gal Harmon's thriller "Bnei Gebal" explores ancient Phoenician myths and a 1997 spy plot.
  • The novel is a prequel to "Mayim Shketim" and features a Shayetet 13 commando.
  • The book is set during a sensitive period in Israeli military history.
  • It examines the similarities between Israeli forces and their adversaries.
  • The reviewer criticizes the novel's depiction of a war-wounded veteran's relationship.
  • The book is praised for its engaging narrative and local relevance.

The Israeli thriller "Bnei Gebal" by Gal Harmon, the pen name of Gal Weisberg, offers an engaging read that blends ancient Phoenician mythology with a contemporary espionage plot set in 1997. The novel follows Erez, a Shayetet 13 naval commando, who assists an aging intelligence agent in searching for a Lebanese spy. This spy is revealed to be part of a secret group connected to the ancient Phoenicians, planning an attack on Israel, which gives the book its title, referencing the Phoenician city of Gebal.

The author, an engineer and reserve officer, has improved his writing in this, his fourth book, which serves as a prequel to his earlier novel "Mayim Shketim" (Quiet Waters). "Bnei Gebal" is noted for its accessible writing style, with short chapters and a unique layout that makes for a fast-paced reading experience. The novel's setting in 1997, a period marked by significant Israeli military events like the Helicopter Disasters and the Naval Commando Disaster, adds a layer of nostalgia and relevance for readers who served at that time, particularly in the security zone in southern Lebanon.

The book delves into the similarities and differences between Erez and his Lebanese adversary, exploring themes of historical motivation, elite training, and covert operations. It also touches upon the parallels between Israeli, French, and US intelligence agencies. While the novel raises questions about the morality of warfare and the justification for self-defense, it ultimately suggests that terrorist organizations intentionally harm civilians, whereas Israel strives to avoid civilian casualties. The reviewer notes that the right to self-defense is not contingent on being morally superior to one's enemies.

A point of contention for the reviewer is the novel's conclusion regarding Erez's personal life. As a prequel, the story must align with "Mayim Shketim," where Erez is a bachelor who separated from his love. The book attributes this separation directly and inevitably to Erez's injury and inability to have children. The reviewer finds this portrayal regrettable, arguing that it downplays the resilience of many war-wounded veterans and their partners in Israel, suggesting that such difficulties can be overcome. Despite this reservation, the reviewer praises "Bnei Gebal" as an enjoyable, informative, and distinctly Israeli thriller, lamenting that Harmon did not further explore the potential for a fantasy-thriller blend given the rich historical and mythological elements present.

Makor Rishonימין · ירושלים

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

תרבותנושא

התחברות ל-baba News

התחברו כדי לעקוב אחרי מערכות, נושאים ואנשים.

או קוד במייל

מוזכרים

פתיחת המבזקים