Israel's Economic Growth Appears Strong But Masks Underlying Complexities
תומצת מתוך Calcalist על ידי baba
Israel's economy has reported strong GDP growth of 8% and low inflation of 1.1% in the third quarter, alongside a 3.3% deficit. However, these figures are inflated by overseas production, particularly from Nvidia, with adjusted growth significantly lower. Underlying indicators like consumption and housing prices suggest a more moderate economic picture. Geopolitical risks and reliance on a single company create significant uncertainty for future economic stability and policy.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Israel's reported 8% GDP growth and 1.1% inflation are misleading due to significant overseas production, notably by Nvidia.
- Excluding Nvidia's contribution, Israel's third-quarter GDP growth was only 4%, with overall 2023 growth closer to 2.8%.
- Low inflation and a decrease in semi-durable goods consumption contradict the notion of an overheating economy.
- Geopolitical instability and reliance on Nvidia's volatile stock introduce substantial risks to foreign investment and revenue.
- The low deficit is largely due to under spending in civilian sectors, while defense costs and potential cuts to US aid pose future fiscal challenges.
- A widening trade deficit and political uncertainty further complicate the economic outlook, requiring a more realistic policy approach.
Recent economic data from Israel presents a seemingly rosy picture, with the Central Bureau of Statistics reporting an 8% annual growth rate for GDP in the third quarter, significantly exceeding forecasts. Concurrently, October inflation dropped to 1.1%, its lowest point since April 2021. The Treasury also reported a 12-month deficit of 3.3% of GDP, well below the 4.9% annual ceiling. This combination of rapid growth, stable prices, and a healthy fiscal balance is rare and often indicates that the reported figures do not tell the whole story.
The apparent economic boom is described as a mirage, largely due to the inclusion of overseas production by companies like Nvidia (formerly Mellanox). When this is excluded, Israel's third-quarter GDP growth was only 4%, half the official figure. For the fourth consecutive quarter, official growth has outpaced growth excluding overseas production, sometimes by a significant margin. While the official annual growth for 2023 is projected around 5.5% to 5.6%, excluding Nvidia's contribution brings it closer to 2.8%. This discrepancy is particularly evident in exports, where the official figure shows 39.5% annual growth compared to 18.4% when excluding overseas production.
Despite the headline figures, underlying economic indicators suggest a more moderate reality. Private consumption rose by 6.4% annually in the third quarter, a slowdown from the previous quarter's 17% rebound. Notably, consumption of semi-durable goods actually decreased. The low inflation rate, with the consumer price index falling in October and annual inflation at 1.1%, contradicts the notion of an overheating economy that an 8% growth rate would typically suggest. Housing prices also show a cooling trend, with a 1.5% year-on-year decrease in August-September.
Economists at S&P, while acknowledging the robust growth, warn that foreign investment, a key driver, is highly sensitive to political and geopolitical instability, potentially leading to capital flight. The reliance on Nvidia, whose stock has recently seen significant volatility and whose operations are central to US-China tech tensions, introduces considerable risk. The low deficit is also attributed to under spending in civilian sectors rather than fiscal discipline, while defense spending has exceeded budget plans. Furthermore, future revenue streams are uncertain, with potential decreases as Nvidia's tax contributions normalize and the US military aid package faces potential changes.
The economic outlook is further complicated by political uncertainty, including the potential for a prolonged period without an approved budget or even a government. This could lead to paralysis and hinder necessary reforms. The trade deficit has also widened significantly, driven by increased imports of machinery and equipment, potentially weakening the shekel and challenging the low inflation narrative. While the Israeli economy is stable and growing at a healthy pace, the official figures present an exaggerated picture, and future policy decisions should be based on a more realistic assessment that accounts for the exclusion of overseas production and the inherent risks.
לא אותו אירוע: ידיעות אחרות שחולקות עם הידיעה הזו אנשים, מקומות או נושא. רקע, תגובות והמשכים.