Documentary on Naomi Shemer Highlights Cultural Exclusion of Right-Wing Figures
תומצת מתוך Makor Rishon על ידי baba
A documentary on Naomi Shemer reveals the harsh criticism and exclusion she faced from Israel's cultural elite after expressing right-wing views. The film highlights how prominent figures like Nahum Barnea and Dan Miron attacked her work, with poet Natan Zach admitting her politics were the reason for his critique. This experience plunged Shemer into depression and serves as a broader example of the left-wing cultural establishment's ostracism of right-wing creators, a phenomenon the article argues has intensified since the 1977 political revolution and poses a threat to Israel's democratic society.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- A documentary on Naomi Shemer highlights her exclusion by Israel's cultural elite for her right-wing political views.
- Journalist Nahum Barnea and critic Dan Miron are cited for their harsh attacks on Shemer's work.
- Poet Natan Zach admitted Shemer's political stances were the reason for his criticism of her songs.
- Shemer's friend Rivka Michaeli stated the criticism led to Shemer's depression.
- The article argues Shemer's experience exemplifies a broader pattern of left-wing cultural boycotts against right-wing figures.
- This exclusion, the article claims, has intensified since the 1977 political revolution and threatens Israeli democracy.
A recent two-part documentary on the late Israeli singer-songwriter Naomi Shemer, aired by the Public Broadcasting Corporation during the Sukkot holiday, focused on lesser-known and challenging aspects of her life. Directed by Shi Lahav and Ron Omer, the film explored Shemer's strained relationship with her mother, her divorce from actor Gideon Shemer, and her years raising their daughter Lali alone. Crucially, it also highlighted the significant animosity Shemer faced from Israel's cultural and media elite after she expressed support for the political right.
The documentary featured harsh criticisms leveled against Shemer by prominent cultural figures. Journalist Nahum Barnea wrote that he would cross the street to avoid her, a statement made after Shemer quoted her second husband, Mordechai Horowitz, who had made controversial remarks about Arabs. Literary critic Dan Miron, in a lengthy 1980s essay, delivered a scathing critique of Shemer's lyrics and music, labeling her work as nationalistic kitsch and questioning her artistic ability. While Miron did not explicitly link his criticism to Shemer's political views, poet Natan Zach, a co-editor of the journal where Miron's essay was published, admitted that Shemer's political stances were the reason for his own discomfort with her songs.
Shemer's close friend, Rivka Michaeli, revealed in the film that the harsh criticism, particularly from Miron, plunged Shemer into a period of depression. The article draws a parallel to a similar incident decades earlier when Miron's critique of poet Leah Goldberg's work also led her into a depressive state. The film uses Shemer's experience as a case study for a broader phenomenon of verbal abuse, boycotts, and delegitimization by the left-wing cultural establishment against right-wing creators and cultural figures.
The article details numerous other instances of this exclusion, including the boycotting of poet Uri Zvi Greenberg and author Moshe Shamir for their political shifts, and the cancellation of singer Amir Benayoun's performance at the President's Residence due to an anti-Arab song. It extends this pattern to other fields, such as the judiciary, where legal scholars opposing judicial activism were allegedly overlooked for Supreme Court appointments, citing the example of Professor Ruth Gabizon. The academic and media spheres are also cited, with examples of right-wing academics and journalists facing ostracism and difficulty securing significant positions.
The article posits that this exclusion evolved in two stages: before the 1977 political revolution, it stemmed from ideological disputes and a desire to maintain the Labor movement's cultural hegemony, often demonizing the right. After 1977, with the decline of the left's political dominance, the exclusion became more desperate and extreme, characterized by intense animosity and fear of the right's influence on national institutions like culture, law, and academia. This dynamic, the article argues, has fueled a reciprocal animosity and a desire from the right to dismantle these institutions, leading to potentially dangerous consequences for Israel's democratic fabric.
מוזכרים