Arab Rescuers of Jews Denied "Righteous Among Nations" Title
תורגם ותומצת מתוך Channel 9 על ידי baba
Historian Robert Satloff is highlighting Arab individuals who saved Jews during the Holocaust but have been largely unrecognized by Yad Vashem. While thousands of Jews faced persecution in North Africa, only one Arab, Egyptian doctor Mohammed Helmy, has been officially recognized as a "Righteous Among Nations." Cases like Khaled Abdel Wahab, who hid Jewish women and children, were denied recognition due to perceived lack of secrecy. The lack of recognition is attributed to political sensitivities in Israel and the Arab world's stance on the Holocaust. Satloff hopes Yad Vashem will re-evaluate these historical accounts.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Yad Vashem has recognized over 28,000 "Righteous Among Nations" but no Arabs from Arab countries.
- Historian Robert Satloff has documented numerous Arabs who risked their lives to save Jews during the Holocaust.
- Notable Arab rescuers include Hamza Abdul Jalil, Si Ali Sakkat, and Khaled Abdel Wahab in Tunisia.
- King Mohammed V of Morocco refused to deport Jews and implement racial laws under the Vichy regime.
- The denial of recognition is linked to political sensitivities in Israel and the Arab world's Holocaust discourse.
- Egyptian doctor Mohammed Helmy is the sole Arab officially recognized by Yad Vashem as a "Righteous Among Nations."
Yad Vashem, Israel's Holocaust memorial, has recognized over 28,000 individuals as "Righteous Among Nations" for risking their lives to save Jews. However, historian Robert Satloff highlights that no Arabs from Arab countries are among them, despite thousands of Jews suffering under Nazi occupation and Vichy rule in North Africa. Satloff has spent years gathering evidence of Arab assistance to Jews during this period. In Tunisia, bakers secretly provided extra bread to Jews without ration cards, and Arab women breastfed Jewish infants when mothers lacked food. Islamic scholars in Algeria issued a fatwa prohibiting Muslims from managing confiscated Jewish property, which was reportedly respected. Approximately 500,000 Jews lived in North Africa (Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya), with an estimated 4,000-5,000 perishing. While Jews were dispossessed and forced into labor, mass extermination was averted as the Nazis were expelled from the region by 1943.
Notable accounts include Hamza Abdul Jalil, a hammam owner in Tunis, who hid Joseph Nakkash from an SS raid in December 1942, a rescue confirmed by both the survivor and the rescuer's son. Former Tunis mayor Si Ali Sakkat sheltered a group of Jews who escaped a labor camp at his country estate, providing them with food. Perhaps the most prominent case is Khaled Abdel Wahab, who, upon learning of a German officer's plan to seize a Jewish woman, swiftly moved her and her family to his farm, where he sheltered about 20 women and children until the occupation ended. Although the rescued family applied to Yad Vashem, their request was denied because the Jews were perceived to be living on the farm with German knowledge, not in a secret refuge. Yad Vashem acknowledged Abdel Wahab as a "kind and noble man" but did not grant him the title. Eva Weisel, one of those saved, expressed deep disappointment in a 2011 New York Times article.
The only Arab officially recognized by Yad Vashem is Egyptian doctor Mohammed Helmy, who hid a Jewish girl and aided her family in Berlin. The recognition of Arab rescuers is reportedly uncomfortable for both sides: Israel faces political complexities, while the Arab world grapples with the implications for Holocaust denial or minimization. King Mohammed V of Morocco is also noted for refusing Vichy regime demands to deport Jews and implement racial laws. Yad Vashem acknowledges North Africa's role in the Holocaust, confirming Nazi plans for local Jews that were cut short by the region's liberation in 1943. No new applications for Arab rescuers have been submitted. While these individuals are being honored in the US and Europe, with trees planted in their names in "Gardens of the Righteous," Satloff hopes Yad Vashem will reconsider these cases with new documentation.
מוזכרים