Israel Should Monetize Its Military Knowledge Shared With US
תומצת מתוך Makor Rishon על ידי baba
An Israeli opinion piece argues that Israel should charge the U.S. for the military knowledge and battlefield experience it shares, likening the current situation to a bad deal. The author contends that Israel's real-world testing of weapons significantly benefits U.S. defense industries. The piece suggests that ending U.S. military aid would foster a healthier, more mutually beneficial relationship based on mutual respect and financial gain for Israel.
הידיעה ב-5 שורות · תקציר של baba
- Israel should charge the U.S. for military knowledge and battlefield experience it shares, according to an opinion piece.
- The author argues Israel's real-world weapons testing provides a marketing advantage to U.S. defense industries.
- Decades of Israeli Air Force feedback to U.S. manufacturers are valued more than U.S. aid, the article claims.
- Former President Trump suggested the U.S. might end military aid to Israel as it no longer needed it.
- The article advocates for Israel to appoint 'agents' to negotiate compensation for shared military intelligence and improvements.
An Israeli opinion piece argues that Israel should leverage its extensive military knowledge and battlefield experience, which it currently shares freely with the United States, to its financial benefit. The author uses an analogy of a baker's son charging a beggar rent to sleep in the bakery, only to find the beggar's agreed-upon duties did not include lighting the oven, leading to a more complex arrangement where the beggar was paid for both sleeping and lighting the oven. This, the author suggests, mirrors Israel's situation with U.S. military aid, which he characterizes as a "bad deal" for Israel.
The article contends that the value of Israeli military technology lies in its real-world testing and refinement on the battlefield, a process that also improves American weaponry used by Israel. This constant testing, including significant human risk and cost to Israel, provides a substantial marketing advantage to U.S. defense industries without requiring direct U.S. combat. The author points to the Israeli Air Force's feedback to U.S. aircraft manufacturers over decades as an example of knowledge transfer whose value exceeds the total U.S. aid received during the same period.
Citing a 2016 interview where then-President Donald Trump suggested the U.S. might end military aid to Israel because it no longer needed it, the article posits that American defense companies are the primary drivers behind continued aid requests. It argues that Israel has historically demonstrated self-sufficiency, inventing weapons like the Uzi and Galil during U.S. arms embargoes and developing cost-effective alternatives when necessary, as seen in Ukraine's reliance on drones.
The piece also references former U.S. Secretary of State Alexander Haig's description of Israel as an "unsinkable aircraft carrier" for the U.S., suggesting this strategic asset is provided to America for free due to the aid relationship. The author advocates for Israel to adopt a business-like approach, appointing "agents" to negotiate fair compensation for the intelligence, combat methods, and system improvements it shares with the U.S., thereby transforming the relationship from one of perceived dependency to one of mutual benefit and financial gain.