Israel Debates Public Transport on Shabbat Ahead of Elections
The debate over public transportation on Shabbat is resurfacing in Israel, with polls showing majority support for its operation. While limited services exist, recent years have seen cancellations. Political parties are divided, with some advocating for local autonomy and others seeking to maintain the status quo. Experts highlight the issue as one of social justice, impacting those without private vehicles, and suggest potential solutions like charging for services or establishing government-backed systems for equitable access.
הידיעה ב-6 שורות · תקציר של baba
- A July 2026 poll indicates 74% of Jewish Israelis support public transportation on Shabbat.
- Former Transportation Minister Miri Regev canceled approximately 60 bus routes operating on Shabbat.
- Tel Aviv's "Naim BaShav" voluntary shuttle service has transported over 30,000 passengers weekly.
- Political parties like "The Democrats" and "Achim" support local autonomy for Shabbat transport decisions.
- Experts frame the lack of Shabbat public transport as a social justice issue, restricting mobility for many.
- Charging for services like "Naim BaShav" is proposed to enable wider participation by municipalities.
The future of public transportation on Shabbat is poised to re-emerge as a significant public issue in Israel, particularly following upcoming elections. This topic has become a focal point in the ongoing debate between secular-liberal and religious-Haredi factions, with polls indicating broad public support for Shabbat public transit. A July 2026 survey by "Israel Hofshit" found 74% of Jewish Israelis favor some form of public transportation on Shabbat.
While limited public transport operates on Shabbat, primarily in Arab municipalities and Haifa, along with some intercity routes and Tel Aviv's "Naim BaShav" voluntary shuttle service, recent years have seen a reduction. Under former Transportation Minister Miri Regev, approximately 60 bus routes operating on Shabbat were canceled over two years, with an additional 18 canceled in 2025 alone, citing operational efficiency and low demand. Regev maintained the status quo regarding Shabbat observance.
Political parties are divided on the issue. "The Democrats," "Yisrael Beiteinu," and "Achim" support local autonomy for municipalities to decide on Shabbat transport based on community character. The Likud opposes changes, seeking to preserve the status quo. Yair Golan's "Democratic Party" proposes limited Shabbat transport in secular or mixed areas, respecting Shabbat in religious zones, with local authorities making the final decision. This stance has drawn sharp criticism from Shas, which argues it undermines the country's Jewish identity.
Avi Maoz's "Zeut" party, with Moshe Feiglin, presents a nuanced position, opposing a blanket ban but not advocating for immediate changes. Their approach suggests distinguishing between state institutions and local areas, empowering residents to decide. Former Prime Minister Naftali Bennett, once seen as blocking such initiatives, now supports Shabbat public transport in any city that desires it, allowing local choice regarding Shabbat observance.
Experts like Meital Lehavi, Deputy Mayor of Tel Aviv, Sivan Shmuelovitch of the 15 Minutes organization, and Tamar Keinan of "Tachburah Le'Kol Yom" emphasize that the lack of Shabbat public transport is a matter of social justice, impacting those without private vehicles. They argue it restricts freedom of movement and encourages private car ownership. Lehavi suggests charging for services like "Naim BaShav" could enable more cities to join and improve service, while Keinan views this as a temporary measure, advocating for a government-backed system for equitable access. Shmuelovitch points to metropolitan authorities as a framework for future progress, stressing the need for government regulation to ensure equality across municipalities.
מוזכרים