Temporary Appointments Hamper Services, Threaten Budgets, Expert Says

The ongoing issue of vacant leadership positions and temporary appointments in Israeli government ministries and institutions is negatively impacting public services and potentially threatening budgets, according to Hassan Tawafra, former Director General of the Authority for Economic Development of the Arab Community. Tawafra explained that while the effects may not be immediately apparent to citizens, the quality of services, which rely heavily on government bodies, can decline due to the absence of permanent leadership capable of making long-term decisions.

Several key institutions are currently operating under interim management. The National Insurance Institute has been led by an appointee since 2024, with their term extended until January 2027. Israel Land Authority also faces instability, with Yehuda Eliyahu serving as an appointee while a permanent replacement is sought, and Israel Railways is functioning without a permanent director general. Tawafra suggested that some ministers may prefer temporary appointments as they allow for greater influence over institutional operations, often at the expense of professional staff and the public interest.

The Prime Minister's own office has been led by an acting director general since 2025, following the departure of Yossi Shelly. Tawafra highlighted the particular impact on the Arab community, especially with the approaching end of the multi-year government plan (Decision 550) for the economic development of the Arab community, which has a budget of approximately 30 billion shekels and covers areas like education, employment, and health.

The lack of a permanent head for the Authority for Economic Development of the Arab Community could hinder the preparation of a new five-year plan, potentially disrupting hundreds of programs and projects. Tawafra also addressed the underrepresentation of Arabs in senior government positions, encouraging qualified individuals to apply for roles despite potential biases, and noting that their presence can influence critical decisions affecting the Arab community.

Tawafra concluded that the next government will need to address these critical appointments to restore stability, warning that the cumulative effects of administrative vacancies on services, planning, and public policy will become increasingly apparent over time.