Sign in to baba News

One account across the web, iPhone and Android — your subscription follows it.

or use an email code

Welcome — one more step

News Plus opens the cross-newsroom layer — who covered a story, who didn’t, and how each one worded it.

  • Unlimited follows
  • Alerts for what you follow (in the app)
  • Story alerts (in the app)
  • Hide read stories (in the app)
  • The daily brief by email
  • Headlines side by side
  • Who reported first
  • The whole archive
  • Your reading diet
  • Duki without the monthly limit

Eligible new subscribers get 7 days free, then $34.99 each year. Renews automatically until cancelled. Cancel any time in your account. Subscription terms.

Your subscription also unlocks the app.

Search stories

Type at least two characters. Results come from every newsroom baba reads.

to move · to open · esc to close

Live Terminal

Sign in to baba News

Sign in to keep asking. News Plus removes the daily limit.

or use an email code

Keep the whole picture

News Plus opens the cross-newsroom layer — who covered a story, who didn’t, and how each one worded it.

  • Unlimited follows
  • Alerts for what you follow (in the app)
  • Story alerts (in the app)
  • Hide read stories (in the app)
  • The daily brief by email
  • Headlines side by side
  • Who reported first
  • The whole archive
  • Your reading diet
  • Duki without the monthly limit

Eligible new subscribers get 7 days free, then $34.99 each year. Renews automatically until cancelled. Cancel any time in your account. Subscription terms.

Your subscription also unlocks the app.

Culture07:35 · 10m ago

Four Species Symbolize Growth and Prayer for Rain on Sukkot

By יאיר פריד
Translated & summarized from Behadrei Haredim by baba
The story · English

A commentary on the biblical commandment to take the "four species" during the Sukkot festival, as described in Leviticus 23:40, explores the deeper meanings behind this practice. The verse instructs followers to take "a fruit of the citron tree, branches of a dense tree, branches of a willow, and branches of a thick tree, and you shall rejoice before the Lord your God for seven days." The author notes that the Torah does not explicitly name the species, instead describing them by characteristics, leaving it to tradition to identify them as the etrog (citron), hadas (myrtle), aravah (willow), and lulav (palm frond).

The article questions why these specific items, three of which are not typically eaten, are chosen to celebrate the harvest. It also delves into the Talmudic concept that the four species must be taken as a single unit, and that if one is missing, the commandment is not fulfilled. Furthermore, it examines the practice of holding the lulav in the right hand and the etrog in the left, and why the blessing is recited specifically over the lulav, often attributed to its height.

The author proposes that the key lies in viewing the four species as representing an entire tree in its stages of growth: the palm frond as the trunk, the myrtle as the branches, the willow as the leaves, and the citron as the fruit. This complete representation of a tree, from root to fruit, symbolizes growth itself. The commandment, therefore, focuses on the vitality of nature and God's role in it, rather than on sustenance.

This interpretation explains why non-edible items are used, as the focus is on the process of growth, not on the harvest for consumption. The blessing over the lulav is explained by its height, symbolizing the peak of growth and the tree as a whole upon which all other parts depend.

Connecting this to Sukkot, the article references Rabbi Eliezer's statement that the four species are taken to pray for rain, which is crucial for future growth and arrives after the festival. During Sukkot, a time of transition between the past harvest and the uncertain future, holding the complete tree symbolizes gratitude for the past year's bounty and a prayer for the coming year's prosperity. The practice embodies both thanksgiving and supplication, mirroring the prayers for God's help and salvation.

Read the original at Behadrei Haredim
Open the live terminal