Israeli Singers Noa Kirel and Eden Ben Zaken Face Copyright Lawsuit Threat from Egyptian Creators
Israeli singers Noa Kirel and Eden Ben Zaken have received a legal warning alleging copyright infringement over their joint song "Ani Meshakeret" ("I'm Lying"). The warning was sent by attorney Tal Perlman, representing the original Egyptian creators Mustafa Siam, Samah Al-Asri, and composer Mohamed Eirab Al-Saini, who claim the Israeli song copies their viral Egyptian track "Tab Ana Kadab?" ("So Am I a Liar?").
The Egyptian creators, known for their viral social media presence, argue that the Israeli song replicates key elements such as the melody, repetitive structure, recurring phrase, and overall musical composition. They emphasize that their original work, which gained millions of views on YouTube and widespread social media exposure, was used without permission, credit, or compensation.
The legal notice demands recognition of their rights as original creators and owners of the melody, a share of the song's economic rights including publishing and future revenues, and the initiation of negotiations within seven days. Failure to comply will lead to legal proceedings. This development follows a growing controversy around the song and highlights ongoing disputes over intellectual property in the music industry between Israeli and Egyptian artists.
The same event, reported separately by each outlet. Open a few to compare what different newsrooms emphasize — and what they leave out.
Not the same event — other stories that share this one’s people, places, or theme: background, reactions, and follow-ups.