Retired IDF Commander Ofer Winter Responds to Criticism Over Tisha B'Av Message

A recent official statement by IDF Spokesperson Brigadier General Effi Daprin on the eve of Tisha B'Av sparked controversy on social media. The statement, which reflected on the destruction of the Temple and emphasized mutual responsibility with quotes from the Book of Lamentations, drew sharp criticism from journalist Anat Kam. Kam wrote, "An official IDF spokesperson message. There is no need to appoint Ofer Winter as Chief of Staff; the 'Winterization' of the IDF is complete."

Retired Brigadier General Ofer Winter, a respected former IDF commander, responded to the criticism. He noted that some had claimed the IDF spokesperson's tweet proved the "Winterization" of the IDF was finalized, and he smiled at the comment. Winter recalled a defining moment during Operation Protective Edge about 12 years ago when he published a combat leaflet for his soldiers containing verses and prayers, which sparked a broad media campaign. He said, "Back then, some panicked over a campaign accusing a commander of religious zealotry for speaking about faith, the people of Israel, and God."

Winter highlighted the unity among soldiers today, from all parts of Israeli society, religious and secular, right and left, who sing, pray, and fight together. He concluded by emphasizing that faith and connection to heritage are not personal possessions but the strength of the people of Israel, accompanying soldiers for generations. Winter expressed pride in his role in this development and in the current generation of soldiers who understand what and why they fight.

This exchange reflects ongoing debates about religion's role in the IDF and Israeli society, especially around significant dates like Tisha B'Av. Winter's response underscores his commitment to integrating faith and national identity within the military framework.