Simchat Torah Reading Debate: One Aliyah Left, Start 'V'Zot HaBracha' Anew?
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
The story in 3 lines · by baba
- Debate over Simchat Torah Torah reading procedure with one aliyah remaining.
- Question of restarting the 'V'Zot HaBracha' portion.
- Rishon LeZion the Rishon LeZion participated in holiday rituals.
A question has arisen regarding the proper procedure for the Torah reading on Simchat Torah, specifically when only one aliyah (a blessing called for a person to ascend the Torah reading platform) remains. The discussion centers on whether to restart the reading of the portion 'V'Zot HaBracha' from its beginning. The article includes a mention of Rishon LeZion the Rishon LeZion performing the ritual of taking the lulav and etrog, and reciting the hoshanot prayers, in a moment described as an emotional thanksgiving ceremony. This specific observance is presented within the context of the 'Minute from the House of Teaching' segment.
The debate over the Simchat Torah reading protocol is a recurring one, often addressed by rabbinic authorities. The core issue is how to conclude the annual Torah reading cycle when the final portion, 'V'Zot HaBracha,' is read on Simchat Torah. If the congregation has already called up individuals for aliyot earlier in the day, and only one aliyah is left, the question arises whether to begin the entire portion anew to ensure all mitzvot (commandments) associated with the reading are fulfilled, or to simply assign the final aliyah to a portion of the text. This is particularly relevant as the Torah reading concludes the yearly cycle and immediately begins again with the first portion, 'Bereshit.'
Read the original at Kikar HaShabbat