Rabbi Argues Shared Torah Study Fosters Lasting Unity

As the Jewish holiday of Sukkot approaches, a period traditionally marked by calls for national unity, Rabbi Yishai Gozlan offers a unique perspective on why these efforts often fail. In an opinion piece, he draws an analogy between social cohesion and the use of glue, suggesting that many attempts at unity are like using weak adhesives that only last for a short time.

Gozlan identifies several types of "unity glue" that he believes are ineffective for long-term bonding. One such type is "brothers in distress," where unity is forged out of a common enemy or threat. While this can create short-term solidarity, it dissolves once the external threat disappears. Another is the "enemy of my enemy is my friend" approach, which also proves temporary and fades with changing political landscapes or the end of election campaigns.

Instead, Rabbi Gozlan proposes that genuine and lasting unity can be achieved through shared Torah study. He observes from his own experience teaching that when diverse groups engage in studying Torah together, they develop a deep, harmonious connection that transcends their differences in character, style, and identity. This, he argues, is not a superficial or artificial bond but a profound and enduring one.

He cites a passage from the Talmud (Kiddushin) which states that even a father and son, or a teacher and student, who initially engage in Torah study in the same place can become estranged, but they will not leave until they become loving towards each other. This, for Gozlan, is the true "glue" that can unite the Jewish people, offering a powerful alternative to the fleeting unity often promoted during times of political necessity.