Expert: Hamas Defeated Militarily but Not Eliminated

Military analyst Yossi Yehoshua stated that Hamas has suffered a severe defeat in Gaza but cannot be completely eradicated. Speaking on 103FM radio, Yehoshua described the recent operation against a Hamas brigade commander in Rafah as part of a broader campaign targeting the group's leadership and units across Gaza, including Rafah, Khan Younis, and Jabalia. He cited statements from the IDF Chief of Staff indicating Hamas is significantly weakened and incapable of restoring its former capabilities, pointing to the Israeli military's control over large parts of the Strip, positions along and beyond the 'Blue Line,' and the ability to strike Hamas targets as evidence.

However, Yehoshua emphasized that a military defeat does not equate to Hamas's disappearance. He believes the organization will retain local operational capabilities and is unlikely to voluntarily disarm. The analyst criticized the notion of 'total victory,' urging a distinction between actual military achievements and the complete elimination of an enemy, stating, "The enemy will never be destroyed, neither in Gaza nor in Lebanon."

Yehoshua also addressed the public perception, noting a disconnect between soldiers' battlefield successes and the narrative of not achieving victory in Gaza. He highlighted the challenge of future governance in the Strip, suggesting that while direct Israeli control over two million Palestinians is undesirable, a viable alternative for effective management and security remains elusive.

Furthermore, Yehoshua expressed doubt that Hamas would disarm voluntarily in the foreseeable future, even with international plans and potential economic investments. He concluded by calling for a broader historical analysis of the October 7th events, considering not only the immediate lead-up but also prior Israeli political and military decisions.