Traffic Lawyer Warns of New Israeli Enforcement Methods

Traffic law expert Attorney Nir Shalom is alerting the public to significant changes in how traffic violations are being enforced in Israel, following a recent reform. Police are now utilizing municipal security cameras to issue tickets for various offenses, not just speeding. Officers can monitor live feeds from these cameras to identify infractions like mobile phone use or not wearing a seatbelt, then generate tickets that are mailed to drivers. "Any innocent municipal camera meant for city security can become a full-fledged police traffic camera," Shalom stated.

The reform also shifts traffic violations from a criminal to an administrative process. Previously, drivers could contest tickets in traffic court before a judge, presenting personal circumstances or technical flaws. Now, these cases are handled administratively by appointed adjudicators, with all communication in writing. Shalom expressed concern that this administrative process lacks the human element of a courtroom and lowers the burden of proof required for conviction, moving from reasonable doubt to a balance of probabilities, making it harder for drivers to contest tickets.

Furthermore, speed camera calibration has reportedly been adjusted to a lower threshold, meaning fewer speed deviations are needed to trigger a ticket. The introduction of average speed cameras over segments, similar to systems in Europe, is also anticipated, rendering traditional braking before cameras ineffective. Shalom highlighted that these changes disproportionately affect ordinary drivers and those whose livelihoods depend on driving, citing examples of delivery drivers accumulating points and facing automatic license suspension for minor, work-related infractions.

Shalom also offered critical advice for drivers stopped by police: avoid admitting guilt, even with apologies like "I'm sorry." He explained that such statements are recorded as admissions and can be used against the driver in the administrative process, making it nearly impossible to appeal the ticket. He advised drivers to remain calm, avoid immediate confessions, and explore legal options instead.