Top Rabbis Backed Replacing Veteran Lawmakers Amid Public Demand for Change
A recent decision within the Haredi political sphere to replace veteran lawmakers Moshe Gafni and Uri Maklev on the United Torah Judaism list has sparked controversy, despite years of public calls for renewal within the community's representation. The article argues that this move, driven by public sentiment and a desire for fresh leadership, is a necessary response to the perceived stagnation in Haredi politics, where seats have often seemed to pass down through generations.
The decision was reportedly influenced by widespread dissatisfaction within the Haredi public following a challenging term in the governing coalition. Leaders, including Rabbi Dov Lando, head of Degel HaTorah, initiated internal surveys and sent emissaries to gauge public opinion, which indicated a significant demand for change ahead of the upcoming elections. This was not seen as an act of ingratitude but as a public duty to listen to the electorate and ensure the best representation for the Haredi community.
Following the announcement of the replacements, a counter-campaign emerged, with some labeling the move as "beheadings" and "humiliation." The article contends that these critics are primarily those who fear losing their own positions of power and influence. It acknowledges the significant contributions of Gafni, who served for 38 years, and Maklev, described as a dedicated and diligent parliamentarian, but asserts that gratitude does not necessitate indefinite tenure.
Rabbi Lando, 96, personally refuted claims that the decision was made by others, stating unequivocally, "I alone decided." He apologized for speaking loudly, explaining that "one responds to a lie in a loud voice." This clarification aimed to silence rumors that he was being manipulated by associates.
Discussions leading up to the decision also included a more radical proposal from Rabbi Moshe Hillel Hirsch to replace all four Degel HaTorah representatives. However, Rabbi Lando favored a more balanced approach, preserving parliamentary experience while introducing new faces. The new candidates, Moshe Rosenthal and Yehuda Weissfish, were proposed by Rabbi Lando and Rabbi Hirsch, respectively, and both possess substantial public service backgrounds. The article concludes by emphasizing that public service is a mission, not a family inheritance, and that honoring past service does not preclude bringing in new talent.
