Rabbis and Doctors Confer on Yom Kippur Fasting Safety

Dozens of rabbis and religious arbiters convened this week for a unique study conference organized by 'Hora'ah B'Yisrael' (Guidance in Israel), focusing on the medical and halachic (Jewish law) considerations of fasting during Yom Kippur.

The central discussion featured Dr. David Morel, who presented the physiology of fasting and its health implications, particularly concerning the avoidance of food and drink in various medical conditions. Rabbis shared common questions they receive annually regarding fasting, which Dr. Morel analyzed from a clinical perspective, explaining the medical significance in accessible terms.

Discussions covered chronic and diabetic patients, differentiating between those stable enough to fast under supervision and those at risk of hypoglycemia. The importance of hydration for the elderly to prevent life-threatening dehydration was also clarified. Safe methods for taking life-saving medications during the fast without regular water were addressed.

Rabbi David Lichtman delivered a detailed lecture on managing diabetes during the fast, outlining precise medical and halachic guidelines for diabetics. Following the medical data review, a deep discussion ensued between the religious arbiters and Dr. Morel, weighing factual medical data against the halachic principles of 'pikuach nefesh' (saving a life) and 'choleh sheyesh bo sakana' (a dangerously ill patient).

The participants reached a consensus on unified guidelines for the public, emphasizing that preserving health and adhering to medical instructions when fasting could endanger life is a religious commandment. The conference concluded with a call for the public to consult with rabbis and doctors in cases of medical doubt to ensure a safe Yom Kippur.