Israeli Rabbi Praises West Bank Settlement Growth, Challenges Media Narrative on Violence
In response to a somber post by Haaretz journalist Yarden Michaeli expressing concern over the Israeli government's expansion of settlements in northern Samaria (West Bank), Rabbi Sefi Geldzahler, head of the Beit Midrash 'The Great Spirit,' posted a surprising video that received unexpected praise, including from Haaretz reporter Meirav Moran. Michaeli had lamented the government's reestablishment and expansion of four uprooted settlements, describing the area as largely unvisited by Israelis or the military and dominated by Palestinians, conveying a tone of despair.
Rabbi Geldzahler, a resident of Nofei Prat, countered by highlighting the security benefits and fulfillment of the Zionist vision brought by the new farms and settlements established during the current government term. He framed his video as an interview with Michaeli, emphasizing the positive aspects of settlement growth and security, which Moran acknowledged despite their differing views, calling his approach impressive. This exchange has led to plans for a joint podcast to discuss their disagreements and explore the issues further.
Geldzahler also revealed he received an invitation from a left-wing religious colleague for a joint tour of the hills to examine alleged settler violence firsthand. Addressing the widespread media portrayal of settler violence, he identified three sources: provocateurs linked to Shin Bet who allegedly incite tensions, retaliatory acts by settlers in response to provocations by neighboring Palestinians, and a small minority of violent individuals present in any large population. He stressed that this violence does not represent the broader settler community.
The rabbi criticized the lack of official Israeli public relations efforts to clarify the complex realities on the ground and intends to conduct the planned tour soon to provide a more nuanced perspective. He described the issue as a complicated "tangle" rather than a straightforward problem of settler aggression.
