Jerusalem Hospital Ordered to Pay Half a Million Shekels to Patient Injured by Hazard

A 70-year-old oncology patient who fell on a hazard in the ambulance area of Shaare Zedek Medical Center in Jerusalem will receive approximately 500,000 shekels in compensation and legal expenses, ruled the Jerusalem Magistrate's Court. The incident occurred in 2020 when the patient, who was receiving preventive treatment, tripped over a metal plate placed on the ground, breaking his jaw and sustaining multiple injuries, including to his face, shoulder, and legs. He underwent surgery to reconstruct his hip joint, which resulted in one leg being shortened, causing ongoing limping and difficulty walking.

The hospital argued that the patient was partly responsible for the fall because he was adjusting his pants at the time, and also claimed his life expectancy was limited due to his illness. However, Judge Orna Sandler-Eitan rejected these defenses, stating that adjusting pants is a natural action and does not negate the hospital's duty of care. She accepted the testimony of the patient's doctor that his cancer was inactive and estimated his remaining life expectancy at ten years, far exceeding the hospital's claim.

The court found that the hospital was negligent for placing the hazard without any fencing, signage, or warning, especially since the metal plate's color blended with the floor. The judge emphasized that visitors to a hospital entrance have the right to expect a safe environment and should not have to watch their steps obsessively. The patient’s daughter testified that his condition deteriorated significantly, requiring assistance with basic tasks.

The court awarded the patient 355,000 shekels for pain, suffering, and assistance needs, plus about 88,500 shekels for legal fees and expenses. The ruling highlights the hospital's responsibility to maintain safe premises and rejects partial liability claims against the patient unrelated to his pants adjustment. The case was represented by attorney Dudu Ben Azri for the plaintiff and attorney Hali Toren for the hospital.