Israeli Rabbis Urged to Take Active Political Roles Ahead of Crucial Elections
As Israel's election approaches, the debate resurfaces over whether rabbis should openly express political opinions. Given the critical nature of political decisions shaping the country's future, there is a strong argument for wise scholars with clear values and practical abilities to participate actively. Public leaders, including rabbis, will increasingly be expected to voice their views on fundamental election issues and practical matters.
Opponents argue rabbis should limit themselves to general ideological statements, avoiding the divisive and often coarse political arena to preserve the sanctity of Torah values. However, politics in Israel is a vital public domain where life-and-death decisions are made about the nation's identity, security, social resilience, and resource allocation. Such decisions require input from individuals with deep ethical understanding and a structured worldview on Israel’s national existence.
The article draws on Jewish tradition, contrasting the Christian separation of religious purity from political involvement with the Jewish model exemplified by Moses and Jacob, who engaged directly in practical leadership and governance. Moses’ appointment of Joshua as leader underscores the necessity for leaders to handle both idealistic values and the practical challenges of public life, including opposition and conflict.
While not every scholar is suited for political engagement, those with both solid ethical frameworks and practical skills should participate. Criticism and personal attacks against such rabbis should be seen as a testament to their honorable role rather than a detriment. The late Rabbi Drukman is cited as a prime example of a Torah scholar who combined spiritual depth with political acumen, whose absence is deeply felt at this critical time.
The author, retired Colonel Meir Harel, head of the Hesder Yeshiva in Modiin, emphasizes the importance of learned rabbis stepping into the political sphere to guide Israel through its pivotal elections and challenges.
