Former Shin Bet Chief Links Israel’s Leadership Failures to Rising Internal Hatred

Former Shin Bet head David Zini recently criticized Israel's political leadership, drawing parallels between the extreme internal divisions in first-century Israel and today’s political climate. He argued that "baseless hatred" within Israeli society is not a root problem but rather a consequence of dangerous, disconnected leadership. Zini emphasized that criticism should be directed at the leadership, which either fails to manage or actively fuels societal hatred. He cited the corrupt, jealous, and arrogant leadership during the Great Revolt and Bar Kokhba revolt, which led to catastrophic losses including over a million deaths, spiritual devastation, exile, and slavery.

Zini compared this historical failure to the current Israeli leadership under Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. He noted Netanyahu’s initial broad support upon returning from the UN, which eroded due to his harsh rhetoric against political opponents, especially during the Oslo Accords period. This incitement culminated in the assassination of Yitzhak Rabin, an event many on the center-left link directly to Netanyahu’s campaign. Over time, Netanyahu’s discourse grew increasingly hostile toward segments of Israeli society he perceives as opposing him, including academia, media, and the judiciary.

Following the October 7 massacre, Netanyahu adopted a militant stance, branding the conflict a "war of uprising" while allowing hostages to remain captive for months, some of whom were killed. Zini highlighted Netanyahu’s refusal to establish a state commission of inquiry into the massacre, citing ongoing conflict as a reason, and criticized the government’s delay and political maneuvering to avoid a thorough investigation. The government’s recent communication to the Supreme Court revealed plans to resume legislative efforts after the upcoming elections, further postponing accountability.

Zini warned that Netanyahu’s obsession with power has distorted his judgment, leading to denial of facts and targeting perceived internal traitors, with the Shin Bet chief acting as a loyal enforcer. He concluded that, as in ancient times, Israel’s current leadership is corrupt, messianic, jealous, and power-drunk, perpetuating societal hatred. The educational message against "baseless hatred" remains vital but must not obscure the truth that societal healing requires replacing the current leadership.