Israeli Rabbi Criticizes Haredi Leadership for Undermining IDF Soldiers' Motives
Rabbi Kobi Eliraz addresses a controversial statement by a leading Lithuanian Haredi rabbi that appeared to question the pure motives of IDF soldiers, suggesting they seek only to kill rather than defend their people in a war of religious obligation. Eliraz invokes the Talmudic verse from Zechariah, "Who despises the day of small things?" to emphasize the importance of recognizing the significance of Israel's national revival, the return to Zion, and the sacrifices of Israeli soldiers. He argues that while one can debate military policies, it is unacceptable to doubt the soldiers' sincerity or to support enemy claims.
Eliraz expresses disappointment over the silence following the rabbi's remarks, noting that similar comments from others would have sparked immediate criticism, especially if perceived as progressive. He cites Maimonides' ruling that even scholars must participate in a war of religious commandment, underscoring that no one is exempt from this responsibility. He also highlights the availability of military frameworks that accommodate religious lifestyles, countering claims that Haredi observance cannot be maintained during service.
The rabbi stresses that the current generation, despite its complexities and challenges, is part of a redemptive process marked by profound dedication to the nation's security and rebuilding. He recalls the historical opposition of the same rabbi to political splits within the Haredi community and questions why his recent statements have gone unchallenged. Eliraz calls on Haredi leaders to honestly confront reality and Torah sources, recognizing the unique national revival underway in Israel, and to avoid alienating the public or diminishing the authority of religious leadership by ignoring these developments.
He concludes by urging a return to self-reflection and repentance, quoting the sages: "Remove the beam from your own eye," advocating for a balanced view that honors both Torah values and the sacrifices of those defending the Jewish state.
