Israeli Culture Ministry Criticized for Inaction in Global Narrative War

The author, Lihla Sigan, criticizes the Israeli Ministry of Culture for its perceived inaction and "cheap populism" in the ongoing global "narrative war." Sigan argues that instead of issuing empty threats or lamenting fringe films that fuel antisemitism, Israel should be actively promoting works that counter falsehoods.

Sigan specifically addresses the film "Accidental Damage" (or "Nazea"), stating its creators are not challenging Israeli consensus but joining a "narrative of hate" that has fueled unprecedented antisemitism since World War II. She contrasts these creators with the "heroes" of October 7th, labeling the filmmakers as joining a "pseudo-intellectual genre of Israel hatred."

She asserts that Israel is not participating in the global narrative battle, which has been ongoing for three years, allowing enemies to score against an empty goal. Sigan calls for a professional and wise approach, suggesting that instead of complaining, Israel should have told the Venice Film Festival that their choice to support "delusional fringes" was a form of modern antisemitism.

Sigan believes the festival will eventually be ashamed of its decision, comparing it to Holocaust denial industries. She questions whether it is more important to condemn anti-Israeli voices or to promote clear Israeli narratives. As a practical step, she suggests promoting Israeli productions like "Fauda 5," currently number 7 on Netflix, to help it reach number 1, urging individuals to share it on social media and with international contacts.