Ex-Netanyahu Aide Yaakov Nagel Advocates for Increased US Aid

Yaakov Nagel, a former senior security official and close associate of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, is advocating for a substantial increase in U.S. military aid to Israel, arguing that current proposals fall short of the nation's needs. Nagel, who led the negotiations for the 2016 U.S.-Israel military aid agreement, believes Israel should request $9 billion more over the next decade than Netanyahu's current plan.

Nagel's proposal aims to cover existing procurement commitments totaling approximately $25 billion and an additional $15 billion for missile defense. He warns that without sufficient U.S. aid, these costs will burden Israel's national budget, potentially requiring increased taxes or deficits. He also criticizes the notion that foregoing U.S. aid would grant Israel greater political independence, asserting that American influence would persist regardless of financial assistance.

Reflecting on the 2016 agreement, Nagel recalled pushing for higher aid amounts despite U.S. and pro-Israel lobby (AIPAC) resistance. He also noted the significant concession made in that agreement: the gradual elimination of the option to convert aid into shekels for procurement from Israeli industries, a change that benefits U.S. defense contractors.

Nagel also headed a committee that recommended increasing Israel's defense budget to 5% of its GDP, totaling an additional 233 billion shekels over a decade. He argues that the previous defense budget of 3.7% of GDP was dangerously low, especially in light of the threats facing Israel, and that the post-October 7th reality proves the need for a robust military.

He further suggests that while Israel should strive for self-sufficiency in critical defense areas, it should not forgo U.S. support entirely. Nagel believes that continued U.S. backing is essential for diplomatic leverage, citing its role in the UN Security Council and potential support in international legal forums.