Politics · Full coverage

Journalist Guy Peleg Criticizes Supreme Court President Itzhak Amit Over Lack of Support for Judge Oren Silverman

How 2 Israeli newsrooms covered this story — translated into English and compared side by side.

100% right-leaning
Right 2

First reported by Arutz Sheva · 2 hours ago

What happened

Channel 12 legal correspondent Guy Peleg criticized Supreme Court President Itzhak Amit and court leadership for not defending Judge Oren Silverman after a defamation ruling involving MK Simcha Rothman. Peleg expressed concern that Amit might be intimidated by the backlash. The Jerusalem Magistrate's Court recently dismissed Rothman's defamation suit against Peleg and media outlets.

  • 01Guy Peleg criticized Supreme Court President Itzhak Amit for not supporting Judge Oren Silverman.
  • 02Silverman faced public backlash after dismissing MK Simcha Rothman's defamation claim.
  • 03Peleg has no personal ties to Silverman but supports him amid attacks.
  • 04Peleg suggested Amit might be intimidated or reluctant to defend lower court judges.
  • 05Jerusalem Magistrate's Court dismissed Rothman's defamation suit against Peleg and media.
  • 06The court ruled the defendants proved the truth defense in the defamation case.

Summary translated & synthesized from the sources below by baba. Read each original for the full report.

In this story
People
Simcha Rothman
PlacesJerusalem

Full coverage · 2 outlets

The same event, reported separately by each newsroom. Open a few to compare what each emphasizes — and what they leave out.

Now 14Right · Hebrew31 minutes ago
Journalist Guy Peleg Criticizes Supreme Court President Itzhak Amit Over Lack of Support for Judge Oren Silverman
Arutz ShevaRight · Hebrew2 hours ago
Legal Correspondent Criticizes Israeli Supreme Court President Over Judge Silverman's Defamation Case Handling

Related stories

Yinon Magal Strongly Condemns Judge Over Defamation Case Ruling Against MK RotmanJul 30, 2026Court Upholds Channel 12’s Version in Defamation Case Against MK Rotman, Highlighting Media-Judiciary AllianceJul 30, 2026Rothman Launches Sharp Attack on Supreme Court President Yitzhak AmitJun 21, 2026Israeli Bar Association Demands Criminal Probe Into Channel 14 Over Judge Defamation7 days agoProfessor Yuval Elbashan Criticizes Supreme Court President Amid Political CrisisJul 5, 2026Journalist slams Justice Minister Levin over no disciplinary action against Supreme Court judgeJun 23, 2026