Israeli Comedian Ordered to Pay Woman Thousands for Weight-Related Insults During Show
Translated & summarized from Mako by baba
Israeli comedian Vladimir Tamarkin must pay a woman 10,000 shekels after insulting her weight during a stand-up show in Bat Yam. The court ruled his remarks were defamatory despite the coarse nature of comedy. Tamarkin denied the claims but said the case boosted his career.
The story in 6 lines · by baba
- Comedian Vladimir Tamarkin insulted a woman’s weight during a 2022 Bat Yam show.
- Tel Aviv court ruled the insults were defamatory and ordered Tamarkin to pay 10,000 shekels.
- Judge acknowledged rough language in comedy but said humiliation must be avoided.
- Tamarkin denied making the remarks and claimed the woman confused him with other performers.
- The woman sought 50,000 shekels but was awarded 10,000 including legal fees.
- Tamarkin said the case, though saddening, gave his career a significant boost.
Israeli stand-up comedian Vladimir Tamarkin has been ordered by the Tel Aviv Magistrate's Court to compensate a woman thousands of shekels after he insulted her weight during a performance. The woman, attending a Russian-speaking comedy show in Bat Yam last year, was called "fat" by Tamarkin, who compared her weight to that of a boxer and mocked her by saying she resembled his fat cat. Judge Tzipora Ohana Kafesh ruled that while stand-up comedy often involves coarse language, the insults directed at the woman crossed the line into defamation and humiliation, warranting compensation.
Tamarkin, 22, denied making the remarks and argued that the audience expects provocative humor as part of the stand-up experience. He also claimed the woman confused his words with those of other comedians at the event. However, the judge found the woman's testimony credible and determined that the comments about her weight and the "fat cat" analogy were beyond acceptable limits, constituting defamation.
The court awarded the woman 10,000 shekels in damages, including 4,000 shekels for legal expenses, less than the 50,000 shekels she initially sought. The judge noted that the woman’s choice to sit in the front row made it more likely she would be singled out during the show.
In response to the ruling, Tamarkin expressed regret that people were hurt but said the case gave his career a significant boost. He maintained that the court’s decision was unfair and that even if he had made the statements, they should not have led to legal liability. Tamarkin emphasized that his goal is to entertain without intending harm, and despite the controversy, he is pleased with the increased attention to his work.
