Religious Zionists Urged to Learn Humility From Ultra-Orthodox in IDF Draft Debate

The ongoing debate over drafting ultra-Orthodox Jews into the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) often cites the Religious Zionist community as proof that Torah study and military service can coexist. However, this argument may deepen divisions rather than foster understanding. The article calls for introspection, humility, and mutual learning between these communities.

The term "Haredi" is clarified here as referring to those deeply committed to Torah observance who do not view IDF service as a religious obligation, unlike the Religious Zionists who see military service as a mitzvah. Public discourse is often clouded by stereotypes and anger, hindering constructive dialogue. Quoting Rabbi Kook, the author highlights the pain and difficulty in expressing heartfelt concerns without resorting to blame or insults.

The Religious Zionist community, which combines Torah study with IDF service, holds a pivotal role in this debate, especially ahead of upcoming Knesset elections. Yet, rather than positioning themselves as a "model example" to the Haredi community, they are encouraged to reflect on their own challenges, such as transmitting a passionate love of Torah to the next generation and addressing religious dropout rates.

The article suggests that the Religious Zionists could learn much from the Haredi community’s comprehensive lifestyle centered on Torah study, family, and community, without attempting to replicate it wholesale. Strengthening Torah study and connection to the yeshiva world may better equip young Religious Zionists to face life’s challenges, including military service.

Ultimately, the author advocates for abandoning the role of antagonistic "exemplar" in the public debate and instead embracing humility, respect, and listening. Recognizing the strengths of the Haredi world does not weaken the Religious Zionist position but can transform the discourse from conflict to bridge-building, advancing the shared goal of a united Jewish people serving in the IDF.