Hasidic Rebbe Vacations in the Alps Are Not Just Leisure, Expert Explains
During a recent episode of the "Kalman Liverman" show on Kan Reshet Bet, hosts Kalman Libeskind and Asaf Lieberman discussed the annual summer trips of Hasidic rebbes to the Alps, including Austria, Switzerland, and Hungary. They questioned whether these trips are genuine vacations, who finances them, and why Hasidic followers do not envy their leaders. Moshe Weisberg, editor of the ultra-Orthodox news site "B’Chadrei Charedim," clarified that what appears as a luxurious holiday from the outside is viewed very differently within the Hasidic community.
Weisberg explained that rebbes are photographed year-round by a dedicated group of photographers, so even short breaks become highly visible events. He emphasized that Hasidim do not envy their rebbe’s trips because the rebbe’s role is demanding, involving daily personal counseling on marriage, health, and community issues. The rebbe’s short breaks in Europe are seen as necessary rest, not indulgent vacations, often accompanied by a small group including the rebbetzin and aides, with careful arrangements for kosher food and ritual baths.
The conversation also touched on whether followers can join the rebbe during these trips. Weisberg noted that while it is not a leisure activity, some Hasidim do visit for Shabbat after obtaining permission or renting nearby accommodations, creating a smaller, more intimate gathering rather than a mass event. He cited examples such as followers of the Toldos Aharon rebbe who annually visit a Hungarian town near Kerecsend, sometimes even holding ceremonies like brit milah in the rebbe’s presence.
Weisberg contrasted Hasidic leadership with Lithuanian rabbinic leadership, noting that Hasidic rebbes embody a dynastic, royal-like status, while Lithuanian rabbis tend to live more ascetic lives, though they also take occasional breaks. When asked why the Alps are favored destinations, Weisberg humorously suggested it might simply be for the fresh air. The discussion highlighted the complex balance between public perception and the spiritual and communal responsibilities that shape these trips.
