Yair Golan's Military Past Doesn't Excuse Role in 2023 Protest Rhetoric
While former IDF Deputy Chief of Staff Yair Golan's military heroism and service are acknowledged, they do not absolve him of responsibility for his part in the 2023 "draft refusal" and extreme protest discourse, according to an opinion piece.
The author argues that the events of 2023, which saw legitimate public protest intertwine with talk of draft refusal, threats to military readiness, and "civil rebellion" rhetoric, created a perception of internal weakness among Israel's enemies. While not solely responsible for the October 7th Hamas attack, this internal division was observed and exploited by adversaries.
The piece highlights the particular concern of senior former military officials participating in what was termed "non-violent civil rebellion." It posits that individuals who understand military command structures and discipline should not engage in actions that cross dangerous boundaries.
Despite Golan's commendable actions on October 7th, such as assisting in civilian evacuations, the author contends that past military achievements do not grant legitimacy to irresponsible civilian conduct. Those with significant public influence and a distinguished military background are held to a higher standard of responsibility.
Golan is criticized for persistent harsh statements, generalizations against societal groups, and rhetoric that could be used to delegitimize Israel internationally. The article emphasizes that such statements from a former Major General carry significant weight and require caution, restraint, and responsibility, especially during national crises.
The author concludes that true loyalty involves challenging a leader when they go too far, and that a distinguished military past does not excuse disrespectful or offensive civilian behavior. While Golan's actions on October 7th can be recognized, he should also be held accountable for his role in the dangerous discourse of 2023, yet he has not apologized or shown remorse.
