General · Full coverage
Rabbi Aharon Botbol Explains Permissible Carrying Without Eruv and Roasted Chestnuts by Non-Jews
How 2 Israeli newsrooms covered this story — translated into English and compared side by side.
100% right-leaning
Right 2
By יאיר פריד
First reported by Kikar HaShabbat · Jul 16, 2026
What happened
Rabbi Aharon Botbol clarifies that carrying a hotel room key without an eruv abroad is permitted under certain conditions, and roasted chestnuts prepared by non-Jews are allowed despite bishul akum restrictions. He explains leniencies in carrying laws in foreign cities and distinguishes between significant cooked foods and snacks like chestnuts.
- 01Carrying a hotel room key abroad without an eruv is permitted if attached to clothing or carried differently.
- 02Public domain definitions vary; many foreign streets are karmelit, allowing leniency in carrying when necessary.
- 03Lifting a crawling infant is allowed since the child carries itself, but strollers remain forbidden to carry.
- 04Bishul akum prohibits cooking by non-Jews of significant foods but exempts roasted nuts like chestnuts.
- 05Chestnuts are not considered important foods, so eating them roasted by non-Jews is permitted.
- 06The guidance was published in the Achvata newsletter available via WhatsApp and email.
Summary translated & synthesized from the sources below by baba. Read each original for the full report.
Full coverage · 2 outlets
The same event, reported separately by each newsroom. Open a few to compare what each emphasizes — and what they leave out.
Related stories
Rabbi Benjamin Hotta Explains If Hotel Guests Can Take Food Without PermissionAug 12, 2026Rabbi Yaakov Sinai Explains If It's Permissible to Eat Non-Jew-Made Omelets at HotelsAug 4, 2026Rabbi Nahum Nosvacher Addresses Buying Cars During The Three Weeks PeriodJul 6, 2026Rabbi Shmuel Bornstein Explains Kashrut Challenges for Travelers AbroadAug 10, 2026Rabbi Benjamin Hotah Explains Jewish Law on Traveling with Women in a CarJul 5, 2026Rabbi Yaakov Sinai Explains If Using Unimmersed Utensils Is Permissible in Hotels or RestaurantsAug 10, 2026