Amichai Segal Criticizes Itamar Ben-Gvir as Disaster for Israel; Minister Responds Defending His Record

Political commentator Amichai Segal sharply criticized National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir in his weekly column in Israel Hayom, calling another government with Ben-Gvir in a senior role "a disaster for Israel." Segal cited rising murder rates, increased organized crime, and deteriorating public safety since Ben-Gvir's rise, accusing him of causing long-term strategic damage to Israel's image and security. He also criticized Ben-Gvir's controversial symbolism and rhetoric, including displaying a photo of Baruch Goldstein and receiving a sugar hanging noose cake on his birthday.

In response, Ben-Gvir posted a lengthy statement expressing deep personal pain over Segal's accusations, accusing him of arrogance and condescension toward the Religious Zionist sector. Ben-Gvir defended his tenure as unprecedented in achievements, highlighting reforms in prison security, a 75% drop in terror attacks, distribution of 300,000 weapons to civilians, doubling police patrol units, and a significant crackdown on crime and extortion. He also emphasized increased recruitment of ultra-Orthodox officers and efforts to restore state control over the Negev.

Ben-Gvir further claimed his security policies prevented a ceasefire with Hezbollah before an assassination attempt on Nasrallah and that he was the only government member warning about threats from Gaza before the October 7 attacks. He accused Segal of being part of a campaign to exclude him from future coalition governments, specifically to enable a unity government without him. Ben-Gvir concluded by expressing doubt Segal would share his response but urged others to do so.

This exchange highlights the deep political and ideological divisions within Israel regarding security policy and the role of controversial figures like Ben-Gvir in government. The debate also reflects broader tensions about governance, public safety, and Israel's international image ahead of potential new elections or coalition talks.