Israeli Supreme Court Unanimously Blocks Government Decision to Shut Down Army Radio

The Israeli Supreme Court unanimously overturned the government’s decision to close Galei Tzahal (Army Radio), ruling that the decision was influenced by improper considerations related to the station’s broadcast content. Justice Kasher emphasized that the government cannot use its power to silence voices it dislikes, stating, "A government that acts this way operates in a blatantly undemocratic manner, as the foundation of any democracy is the recognition that authorities cannot silence dissenting opinions."

While the justices did not rule out the possibility of closing Galei Tzahal on lawful and substantive grounds, they rejected the current closure decision due to procedural flaws and improper motives. The official reasons given by the government for shutting down the station included claims that it conflicted with IDF principles, that soldiers’ involvement in current affairs was inappropriate, and that the station’s public funding gave it an unfair advantage in the media market. The government also argued that transferring the station to the Defense Ministry or privatizing it was not feasible because the "Tzahal" brand could not be privatized.

Following the government’s closure announcement, several petitions were filed against the decision, including by the Israeli Journalists Association and the Movement for Quality Government. The petitions argued that the decision contradicted recommendations from professional committees, notably one led by the former Defense Ministry Director-General and current IDF Chief of Staff, Eyal Zamir, which had recommended continuing the station’s operation within the IDF. They also cited serious administrative defects such as a rushed timeline, lack of professional consultation, and consideration of irrelevant factors. The petitions warned that shutting down a major media outlet would harm the media landscape and chill journalistic criticism.

The Supreme Court’s ruling marks a significant setback for the government’s media policy and upholds the principle of free speech within Israeli democracy. The government has yet to announce its next steps regarding Galei Tzahal’s future.