General09:51 · Aug 6

Israeli Therapist Urges Parents to Support Yeshiva Sons During Bein Hazmanim Instead of Criticizing

Kikar HaShabbatReligious
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
The story · English

Mordechai Rot, a therapist featured in Kikar magazine, shares a poignant story about the challenges faced by parents of yeshiva students during Bein Hazmanim, the break between yeshiva study periods. He recounts a conversation with a father of four yeshiva sons who struggles with their late waking hours, minimal prayer, and reduced study during the break. The father expresses frustration and anger, often yelling at his sons to wake up and study, but feels this only creates tension and damages their relationship.

Rot explains that yeshiva students endure intense mental, spiritual, and social pressures throughout the study year, leaving them exhausted by the time Bein Hazmanim arrives. He emphasizes that the break is a critical recovery period, not a time for parental supervision or criticism. Instead, parents should offer warmth, understanding, and autonomy to help their sons recharge. Rot highlights psychological concepts such as ego depletion and psychological reactance to explain why criticism backfires, causing sons to resist and withdraw further.

The therapist advises parents to validate their sons' fatigue, avoid nagging, and provide positive reinforcement unrelated to study, such as appreciation for household help or kindness to siblings. He stresses that true fear of God and spiritual commitment are measured by voluntary devotion during free time, not enforced schedules. Rot shares a follow-up from the father who adopted this approach, reporting a peaceful home atmosphere and his son independently waking and studying with joy.

Rot concludes that when fathers stop acting as yeshiva supervisors at home and instead embrace their parental role with love and patience, they restore their sons' spirits and strengthen family bonds. He calls on parents to cherish the moment when a son says, "Dad, you’re not my supervisor, you’re my father," as a turning point toward genuine connection and spiritual growth.

Summary: Therapist Mordechai Rot advises Israeli parents of yeshiva students to replace criticism with empathy during Bein Hazmanim, helping sons recover from intense study pressures and rebuild family bonds. A father's experience confirms that love and autonomy foster better spiritual and emotional outcomes than strict supervision.

Points: - Yeshiva students face intense pressure, making Bein Hazmanim a vital recovery period. - Parental criticism during the break often damages relationships and fails to motivate. - Psychological research supports the need for rest and autonomy to restore self-control. - Parents should offer warmth, positive reinforcement, and avoid acting as supervisors. - A father’s shift to supportive parenting led to his son’s renewed joy in study and family. - The phrase "You’re my father, not my supervisor" signals a crucial need for parental love.

Topic: culture israel_relevant: true Entities: {"people":["Mordechai Rot"],"organizations":["Kikar Magazine"],"places":["Israel"]}

Read the original at Kikar HaShabbat
Open the live terminal