Alan Shearer Criticizes Thomas Tuchel After England's World Cup Semi Loss but Urges Patience

Alan Shearer sharply criticized England coach Thomas Tuchel following the team's 2-1 defeat to Argentina in the 2026 World Cup semi-final, but stressed that Tuchel's tenure should not end despite the disappointment. Writing in a BBC column, Shearer said Tuchel was hired to win the tournament and succeed where England had recently failed in crucial matches. However, he argued that Tuchel did not fulfill this mission against Argentina.

Shearer pointed to tactical errors, including Tuchel's decision to adopt a defensive posture after England took the lead and ineffective substitutions that failed to improve the team's situation. He noted the frustration was heightened by England's real chance to reach their first World Cup final in 60 years. Shearer also highlighted that in the final 30 minutes, when Argentina had to attack and open the game, England's early shift to defense allowed Argentina extended possession and gave Lionel Messi too much freedom, which ultimately led to damage.

Tuchel defended his approach after the match, saying he did not regret his tactics, but Shearer suggested the coach would likely reassess his decisions in the coming days once emotions settled. Despite the criticism, Shearer emphasized that Tuchel should remain in charge. Tuchel's contract, originally set to expire this summer, was extended by two years in February, and he is expected to lead England in Euro 2028, which they will co-host.

Shearer acknowledged that the World Cup failure would increase scrutiny on Tuchel but believed his experience and past successes would help him handle the pressure. He also found positives in England's team spirit and cohesion during the tournament, expressing belief that the team is capable of going all the way in future competitions. Shearer concluded that England would finish the tournament frustrated but hopeful for better outcomes next time.