Rabbi Benjamin Malkoff's Refusal to Participate in Disengagement Led to IDF Promotion

On the anniversary of Rabbi Benjamin Malkoff's passing, Rabbi Shmuel Eliyahu shared a story about Malkoff's decision during the Israeli disengagement plan and its impact on his military career. At the time, Malkoff served as a brigade rabbi in the Northern Command and was asked to assist in the disengagement. He consulted his mentor, Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu, who instructed him not to participate, as his role was unrelated to the operation. Malkoff followed this guidance and refused to take part.

Following his refusal, Malkoff was summoned by his commanders and warned that his decision was serious and could harm his future promotions and assignments. Months later, when the position of Central Command Rabbi became available, Malkoff initially did not intend to apply. However, after consulting Rabbi Mordechai Eliyahu again, he was encouraged to submit his candidacy, with Eliyahu assuring him he would be selected.

During the interview with then Central Command Chief Yair Naveh, the issue of Malkoff's refusal to participate in the disengagement was raised. Naveh asked how Malkoff would respond if ordered to carry out a similar operation in the future. Malkoff replied he would again consult his rabbi and follow his instructions. Despite expecting to be rejected, Malkoff was surprised when Rabbi Eliyahu congratulated him on his appointment before he even shared the interview details. Two weeks later, the official announcement confirmed his appointment as Central Command Rabbi.

After Rabbi Malkoff's death about a year ago, retired General Yair Naveh called the family to explain his reason for choosing Malkoff: "I chose him because he is a man of truth. I want officers who know how to say no."