Israeli Government Pushes Controversial Basic Law on Torah Study to Bypass Military Draft Ruling
The Israeli government has introduced a new Basic Law on Torah Study as a political maneuver to circumvent the Supreme Court's ruling on equal military conscription. This declarative law, intended to become part of the constitution, aims to legitimize and facilitate parallel legislative measures such as canceling arrests of draft-dodging ultra-Orthodox individuals and reinstating subsidies for draft exemptions. The law effectively elevates the status of Torah scholars above that of soldiers, who lack constitutional protections and are subject only to military orders.
The law was fast-tracked through the Knesset's committee rather than the Constitution Committee, reflecting Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's political deal with ultra-Orthodox leaders Itzhak Goldknopf and Aryeh Deri. This move has raised strategic concerns, as the military is reportedly short of 12,000 soldiers, a critical issue highlighted by the IDF Chief of Staff. Avital Sompolinsky, representing the Attorney General, warned that the law poses serious constitutional challenges, undermining the principle of equality and potentially granting blanket military exemptions to Torah students.
Sompolinsky emphasized that the law's vague language, including the term "balances of justice," leaves room for interpretations that could disproportionately favor Torah study over other societal obligations. Opposition lawmakers criticized the law for ignoring the military's contributions and warned of its anti-constitutional nature. Ultra-Orthodox MK Yaakov Asher defended the law by citing a divine promise to the Jewish people, asserting that Torah study ensures Israel's continued existence.
The Basic Law is expected to face legal challenges in the Supreme Court, where it may be struck down for both misuse of constitutional legislation and violation of equality principles. The ultra-Orthodox faction argued that equality is not enshrined in Basic Laws but imposed by the judiciary, thus justifying their privileged status. The political controversy underscores deep divisions over military service and the role of religion in Israeli society.
