General07:14 · 3h ago

Rabbinic Guidance Permits Studying for Weekday Exams on Shabbat Under Specific Conditions

Kikar HaShabbatReligious
Translated & summarized from Kikar HaShabbat by baba
The story · English

Rabbi Aharon Botbol addresses the halachic question of whether it is permissible to prepare for a secular studies exam on Shabbat. The discussion focuses on two main issues: engaging with secular subjects on Shabbat and the prohibition against preparing on Shabbat for weekday activities. According to Maimonides, reading secular material on Shabbat is forbidden, allowing only Torah study. However, Rashba permits reading secular content if it brings enjoyment, a view supported by the Shulchan Aruch and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, who allow leniency. Some pious individuals still refrain from secular reading on Shabbat.

Regarding preparation for weekday exams, the prohibition applies when one could study after Shabbat but chooses to do so on Shabbat due to free time. If the student has already used their free time during the week and cannot complete the material without studying on Shabbat, this is permitted. This is analogous to the Shulchan Aruch’s ruling allowing care for perishable vegetables on Shabbat to prevent loss when waiting until after Shabbat is impossible.

The article also discusses the permissibility of listening to a Holocaust survivor grandmother share painful stories on Shabbat. The Shulchan Aruch emphasizes the mitzvah of "oneg Shabbat" (delighting in Shabbat), advising avoidance of distressing thoughts or stories that cause sorrow. The Mishnah Berurah and Rabbi Ovadia Yosef recommend focusing on joyful and light study on Shabbat. However, sensitivity and respect are urged when the grandmother feels compelled to share, suggesting gently steering the conversation to more pleasant topics while maintaining Shabbat’s sanctity.

This guidance was published in the Achvata newsletter distributed across Israel, with contact information provided for receiving the publication by WhatsApp or email and for synagogue distribution.

Read the original at Kikar HaShabbat
Open the live terminal