New hand-over-mouth rule sparks controversy after Miguel Almirón’s World Cup red card

Miguel Almirón of Paraguay made football history on Saturday morning when he became the first player sent off under FIFA’s new so-called “Pristiani rule,” after covering his mouth with his hand while speaking to an opponent during Paraguay’s win over Turkey. It was the second time in this World Cup that Almirón had been at the center of a disciplinary controversy, after a yellow card against the United States was later corrected by VAR because of a mistaken identification.

Former England striker Wayne Rooney reacted to the rule change, saying, “It’s difficult, he probably didn’t know the law. Emotions took over, but those feelings of guilt will stay with him.” Rooney warned that players could fall victim to FIFA if they hide their mouths while trying to pass tactical instructions to an opponent, adding, “I wouldn’t be surprised if this brings down coaches.”

In Turkey, it was argued that the players on the pitch drew referee Ivan Barton’s attention, but unlike Rooney’s description, this case involved a direct exchange between one player and an opposing player. “It is not clear what he said to Mert Muldur at that point,” the report said.

Zlatan Ibrahimovic also commented, saying Turkey failed to seize their chance. “I expected them to be more dangerous and better, but Paraguay was lucky,” he said. The incident adds another headline to the 2026 World Cup as FIFA’s new enforcement draws criticism and confusion.