New Immigrants Criticized for Importing European Liberalism to Israel

A prominent Israeli commentator, Daniel Roysman, has sharply criticized recent Russian-speaking immigrants to Israel, accusing them of attempting to impose European liberal ideals onto the complex realities of the Middle East. In a widely shared social media post, Roysman argued that these new arrivals, unlike earlier waves of immigration, had opportunities to foster democracy in their home countries but instead are now trying to lecture native Israelis on how to live.

Roysman contends that these immigrants, having recently left countries like Russia, are bringing with them "abstract values" and "political naivety" that disregard historical lessons and the unique security challenges Israel faces. He contrasted them with immigrants from the former Soviet Union in the 1990s, suggesting the current wave is ill-equipped to understand the region's conflicts.

He specifically referenced the Oslo Accords period of the early 1990s, arguing that attempts at peace and increased contact with Palestinians, rather than fostering stability, led to the bloody Second Intifada and numerous casualties. Roysman asserted that past concessions, including efforts to divide Jerusalem or cede territory, have consistently resulted in violence because the opposing side aims for Israel's complete destruction.

Roysman's commentary highlights a perceived disconnect between the expectations of some new immigrants and the historical context and security imperatives of Israel, suggesting their approach is dangerous and detrimental to national security.